Friday, August 15, 2008

None Of Us Is As Dumb As All Of Us

Of course, the title of this post is a reference to the Meetings poster from Despair Inc., but I only used it because Despair doesn't seem to have a poster up about Bureaucracy. And when Despair Inc. lets you down, who is there left to trust?


...



Ok, so I have this situation at work.

You see, I'm assigned to a program where we're using Oracle. For those of you who are unfamiliar with Oracle, it is a very high-end database system. It's also the market leader, and with good reason: it's got very good performance, and when configured properly, it's nearly bulletproof.

But: it's complicated. Oracle needs people with lots and lots of training to run it properly, to keep it tuned and well-managed. We didn't have any people on-hand with that level of expertise, so I and a co-worker got to be trained at my company's expense.

Incidentally, I suspect this is where Oracle makes most of their money. I mean, Oracle licenses are expensive, no doubt; but they just made Ten Grand off of the training that the two of us took! And those classes were just the basic Admin Part 1 and the basic Admin Part 2 classes; we haven't even done all the really fancy stuff yet. Oracle also offers classes specifically for backup and recovery; for performance tuning; for database design; for instruction in the PL/SQL language. It's a racket, I tell you; for a single person to take all these classes, would take several tens of thousands of dollars.

But I digress.

Well, I work for a very big company. And Oracle is a very big company. And big companies, in order to function, have to design "proper channels" for every bit of information, and for every dollar that changes hands, and for every operation. But these systems have one serious flaw:

They're designed by people.

And they're populated by people.

Ok, that's two serious flaws. The two serious flaws are that they're designed by people, populated by people, and there's no permanent way to delete bad information once it gets entered into the system.

Three. The three serious flaws are.... Ok, you get the point.

And when two big companies get together to try to do business, often the systems from one company and the systems from the other company are mutually anathema. One company says you must do X before you do Y; the other says you must do X after you do Y, and so you can't do either X or Y and both companies get mad at you. And then you explain the situation to your boss, who then calls the other guy's boss at the other company, and then they get into a big fight, and the problem never gets resolved until both companies break their rules just this once....

Well, the handling of the billing for these classes has officially gotten all fouled up.

You see, my company has issued each of its employees a corporate credit card, to be used anytime they have to spend money on company business--especially for travel-related expenses, but also for trips to the local computer store, and for training needs. After making the expenditures, the employee receives a bill; and then he files an expense report, which is approved and paid by the company.

In theory.

When all the planets are in the proper alignment.

But! In order to save money, my company has instituted this nifty cost-cutting measure: if you haven't used your card in the last year or so, your account gets deleted and you can't use the card anymore. If you then have new expenses, you have to apply for a new card.

So most of us are walking around with corporate credit cards that don't work.

Our boss told us, "Sign up for this class and put it on your corporate cards." We duly signed up for the class and put it on our cards. My co-worker, shortly thereafter, received a package of course materials; I did not.

After a week or so of waiting, I decided to call up Oracle to see what the trouble was.

My call was routed through Chile, of all places. My co-workers thought this was hilarious.

So after determining what the problem was, I contacted the correct point-of-contact within my company to get my card reinstated. Upon getting confirmation of this, I contacted Oracle again, and they were able to verify the account was active!

When my package of course materials showed up a few days later, they all joked about my "package from Chile" and wondered if I needed to keep it hidden from the Narcs.

Then the course started. And I was the only person on the roster with the words "Not Paid" next to my name.

What!?!?!?!? So I asked the helpful lady at the desk why it said I hadn't paid. She checked the online records, and those records said that I had paid, so I shouldn't worry about it.

Fine. So I took the class; and a wonderful class it was, I might add. Especially because it makes me more employable. And because my company paid for it. (Or so I thought....)

So a week or so later I got the bill from the credit card company. I opened it up, expecting to see a number vaguely resembling that on the printout I'd made when I signed up for the class--something just above five thousand dollars. (That's $3600 for each of two classes, minus a big chunk because of some discounts).

The actual number on my bill: $915.00.

?????

So, I looked over all my records, checking to see where the nine-hundred and fifteen came from. That number was nowhere on any of my printouts, nowhere on any of my receipts. None of my expenditures were anything close to being evenly divisible by 915.

I have no idea where that number came from.

So of course, I'm very hesitant to fill out the expense report just yet. I want to make sure that I'm paying the right amount of money, so it doesn't come to haunt us later on. I mean, my employer would love to get over five thousand dollars worth of training for employees, while paying less than a fifth of that amount; but if we let it slide, eventually it will turn into a huge mess that will consume far, far more than the amount in dispute just in terms of the prorated salaries of the employees who are trying to resolve the situation.

But until it's resolved, I live in fear that the credit card legbreakers are going to be stalking my family. Although they are corporate cards, they are issued in the names of the employees, after all....

So it looks like I get to spend more time calling up women in Chile with lovely (if undecipherable) accents. (So it won't be a total waste, even if I can't get my case resolved....)

Sigh....


...


So what brought all of this up? Well, I was reminded of it today after my wife found this little tale at the site of a family friend. We thought it was very, very funny--but only because it's totally true.

Thursday, August 14, 2008

What Do You Think Of College and Employment?

Roger Z over at Zulu Blog has posted an interesting column, and is soliciting feedback. If you haven't seen it yet, take a look.

He posts an opinion column from the Wall Street Journal, that laments the fact that a four-year college degree is required for so many jobs these days, when they aren't technically needed. After all, there are a few fields--accounting is one of them--where your qualification comes not from any degree you've earned, but from passing the CPA exam. If you pass the exam--and it's a hard exam, and most fail--then you're an accountant, regardless of how well you did in school, or even whether you went.

The author of this column submits the idea that it would be better if most--if not all--jobs were qualified this way, as opposed to requiring the four-year degrees as is done so commonly these days. He argues that the skills required in many jobs don't actually match that well with what is learned in college; and that at any rate, it doesn't really matter where your skills come from (college or otherwise) so long as you can prove you have them.

Now, Arby of the Archives--who we've definitively determined wears women's underwear--weighed in, saying that the generalized critical thinking skills that he and his wife picked up in college were tremendously valuable to them when they later entered the wonderful world of employment. He agreed that they aren't actually using their major-study-area knowledge that much, but that the college experience as a whole is nevertheless a big part of their current success.

I've responded to this (in a comment that isn't yet through comment moderation), that many people do learn their critical thinking skills in college, but that this isn't the only way to get critical thinking skills; my wife's extended family, for instance, is filled with people who never got a degree, but who have enough life experience that they developed those skills anyway. I argue that many people only learn these skills in college, because with the way our society raises and educates our kids, college is the first time that they are playing without a net, with real decisions to make that have real consequences. And at any rate, there are plenty of smart, hard-working people in this world who just don't have the temperament to sit in classrooms for four years--and they need to get matched up with jobs that match their skills, too.

I also posted links to these two previous posts of mine that touch on this topic.

What do you think?


Note: best to post your comments over there. Don't want to steal any of his traffic. :-)

Wednesday, August 13, 2008

Carnival of Homeschooling is Up!

So, after a few months of just being blasé about my homeschooling blogging--which is one of the reasons I started this blog--I've decided to start making the minimal effort again. The Umpty-Umpth Carnival of Homeschooling is up over at Spiritbee's blog!

No, I didn't submit anything this week. Had I done so, it would have been my recent post on Egyptians and Calvin & Hobbes, so if the stuff at the Carnival doesn't float your boat, you can go read that one again.

There were a couple of posts that caught my eye this time around. This post, by Barbara Frank, warns parents--especially homeschooling parents--about the dangers of making the kids the center of their existence. That's a real danger with homeschoolers, because as Barbara says:
I mean, homeschooling takes over your life. You find yourself poring over curriculum catalogs, spending hours on the phone signing your children up for co-ops and lessons and staying up late planning upcoming learning experiences.

And that’s just in the summer! Then there’s all the time you put in working with your children, reading to them, making sure they understand concepts they’re having trouble with, taking them to zoos and museums ….add in feeding them and clothing them and making sure they live in a healthy environment, and you can easily end up living in a child-centered world. And that’s not a good thing.
True, 'dat.

I'm also one of those people who likes to trade stories about people's lives. I love to hear people talk about how they met and fell in love with their spouses; I love to hear stories about the weird things that people's kids have done lately; I love to hear stories about people's hobbies--how they developed their interests, and what kinds of "war stories" they have. And for that matter, I love to hear war stories.

Now that I'm a homeschooling parent, there's another set of stories to throw on the pile: why and how a family decided to start homeschooling, and how they've made it work for them. Along those lines, this post at Home School Online is very interesting. John Edelson talks about a class of parents that he calls "Accidental Homeschoolers." Basically, these are parents who started out with no intention of homeschooling their children, who may in fact be very sour on the wisdom of homeschooling in general; but due to events--troubles at school, poor academic progress, bully or other peer trouble, family issues--have come to the reluctant decision that homeschooling really is the least worst solution for their particular kids.

Mr. Edelson lays out some generalizations about these parents, who may in fact constitute up to half the homeschooling community:
  • Accidental homeschoolers often have the impression that they are unusual in that they are only homeschooling because it’s the best option. Many seem to feel that this sets them apart from other homeschoolers.
  • Accidental homeschoolers’ decision to homeschool often resolves a crisis, or series of crises, with the children, the school, and sometimes within the family.
  • Many accidental homeschoolers have been preoccupied trying to make traditional education work for their children so that when they finally “give-up” on schools and decide to homeschool, they find themselves with no preparation and no real idea what homeschooling means.
  • Accidental homeschoolers start with real trepidation and often with little to no enthusiasm for their endeavor.
  • The number of people starting as “accidental homeschoolers” is increasing now that the public has broad awareness and acceptance of homeschooling.
Anyway, since Tonya's and my decision to homeschool came from a totally different direction, I find the stories of these people to be somewhat strange and fascinating, and I always find I want to hear more.

So... Any homeschoolers out there want to describe your decision process? How did you finally make your decision? How did you make your first years' plans? How did it go? How much "adjustment" did you have to do as you slowly started to figure out all the rookie mistakes you were making?

Then, there's this post that I found amusing. It's about a girl who was doing her copywork practice, when her brother came in and turned on the TV. The dad posts her work, apparently for the whole internet to grade. It's pretty apparent where she was in the paper when the TV went on, because up until that point, the grammar and spelling were actually pretty good....

Anyway, there's a lot of good stuff at the Carnival this week. Check it out....

Tuesday, August 12, 2008

Long Lost Winnie-The-Pooh Stories

So the Pillowfight Fairy has firmly decided that she likes the Winnie the Pooh stories. Note that these are the original A.A. Milne stories, with the illustrations by Ernest H. Shepard--not the red-shirted Pooh of Disney.

Today, during quiet time (known as "nap time" to everyone else, except that the Fairy has decided she doesn't do naps anymore, so she has "quiet time" instead), she decided that A.A. Milne hadn't done enough Winnie-The-Pooh stories, and so she decided to write a little fan fiction.

When I came home today, she presented me with a lovely tape-bound six-page illustrated work of new stories. Aside from the pervasive nihilistic undertones and glorification of gratuitous violence that seem to be a hallmark of her individual writing style, and the occasional misspelling, I was duly impressed.

I decided to share with y'all the fruits of her labor. And in case anyone asks, these works are Copyright 2008, The Pillowfight Fairy. (Which means by publishing them on the web, I'm probably getting in legal trouble. Thankfully, we haven't explained to the Fairy about lawyers yet....)







By the way, sorry about the scans truncating letters off of the pages. The pages the Fairy used happen to be just a wee bit bigger than the scanner glass, and the Fairy likes to "Explore the Space," as it were....

(She also loves the More Cowbell skit that made that phrase famous....)

Four-Eyes

About six months or so I took the Adrenaline Junkie in to get her eyes checked, as one of those innumerable routine doctors' appointments that seem to come all the time when you have three kids.

And, of course, the kids always ask the big question every time you load them up to take them to the doctor: is there going to be a shot today? Well, this time the answer was no. But she was going to get some drops in her eyes, and judging from the volume level of the unhappy victim, that was nearly as bad.

Basically the doctor threw a whole bunch of images up on the wall via projector, and had the Junkie try to identify them: house, airplane, etc. They have to do this with the youngest kids, since they don't necessarily know their letters well enough to tell you that the top line says "E".

And... the results were that the Junkie was developing a little near-sightedness in her right eye.

Thus the drops; the doctor wanted to dilate them to take a look inside and see if there was anything wrong.

His diagnosis at the time was that the left eye was fine, but that the right eye was borderline myopic--just over the edge from what is considered "normal". But he did say that kids are born myopic and often grow out of it; so we scheduled a six-month follow-up appointment to see if her eyesight would spontaneously fix itself.

Well, last week Tonya took her back in. The good news was that it hadn't gotten any worse. But the bad news was that it hadn't gotten any better, either.

So the doctor prescribed glasses. Basically, at this point the goal isn't so much to help her to see better; the goal right now is to get the eye working harder, in hopes that it will correct itself as she grows. So this set of glasses are basically reading glasses--the kind that would be used to help a far-sighted person see better.

Now, we have a bit of a fashion problem here.

The trouble is that in our family, we all have really small heads.

No personal jokes in the comments, please. There's nothing wrong with having really small heads that a well-adjusted family can't handle. And, as they keep telling us, it's not the size that counts, it's what you do with it....

Ahem.

But start with a three-year-old, and then figure that this three-year-old has been skimming the 5th percentile (or less) for head circumference ever since she was born.

Now try to find a pair of glasses that fits her. Good luck with that. Practically everything they tried came out looking horn-rimmed.

Ultimately they picked a pair of frames that was just about the smallest that they offered without having to be special ordered. (And they were pink. They had to be pink. Even three-year-olds take their accessories very seriously.)

Well, today the glasses were ready. What do you think?

Here's what I think.

Most of us, when seeing a picture of a kid, can make a pretty good guess how old the kid is. And even if you're not able to get it to within a year or two, you can at least tell that this one is a toddler or this one is in late elementary school or this one is in high school. To do this, we pick up on age clues. The most obvious of these is, of course, height.

But in a photograph, that clue often isn't there, and our guess of the age of the kid relies much more on the shape of the face, and the bodily proportions. In particular, large heads and tubby bodies tend to be more typical of younger kids; heads that are proportionally smaller, and bodies that are leaner, and legs that are proportionally longer, tend to clue us in that the subject of the picture is older.

The trouble is, our kids are:
  1. Tall for their age. The Adrenaline Junkie is about 85th percentile for height; and
  2. Slender. The Adrenaline Junkie is about 30th percentile for weight, and that's counting the fact that this weight is distributed on a taller frame; and
  3. Small-headed. As I said above, the Junkie is 5th percentile on a good day, and often measures less.
Basically, they have the bodily proportions of much older kids. I sometimes wonder what they'll look like when they get to be teenagers; I suspect they'll have the build of magazine models, much like their mother did.

Now. Put a pair of glasses that's almost too wide on such a face, and it makes the face look longer and thinner, and thus--when you're dealing with a preschooler--much, much older.

Well, when I first saw my three-year-old daughter in glasses today--and especially when I took those pictures and looked at them without all the size context--I nearly freaked.

That three-year-old girl looks like a teenager to me. Especially in this one:

I'm thinking I need to get that shotgun now rather than later....

Monday, August 11, 2008

Boy, This Sure Takes A Lot Of Time, Doesn't It?

So I've discovered the problem that no doubt millions of bloggers have discovered before me.

You write a post.

Someone comments.

You respond to that comment. The response is a little longer than the comment.

The commenter comments back about your response. The commenter unpacks your response, and answers it one paragraph at a time. This comment is longer than the first.

So you respond to that comment. And you answer some points-of-order in the latest comment, then you do a little more exposition, then you do a point-by-point rebuttal. This response is longer than your previous response, longer than either of the comments, and (often) longer than the original post.

Then your Doppelganger decides to drop in, or some of those guys whose ego you stroked last month. And then they start dropping big, long meaty comments. And then you have to respond to those too.

And before you know it, it's 11:20 at night, you've been ignoring your wife, kids, and pets, and you haven't even blogged yet! This is a minor tragedy, if you've been trying to keep to one post a day. (Ok, not so much of a tragedy. I've missed many days this month so far, and the sky hasn't fallen. Yet....)

Solution?

That's right: try a little Meta-blogging!

So. In the absence of other stuff to write about, be it known that I've done a couple of post-length comments tonight on my Good News for California Homeschoolers post and my economics post, The Enemy Is Us.

I've got some good conversations going in the comments sections of both of these posts. Be forewarned, however, that if you post a comment, you might get a response. And then you'll have to answer it.

And you, like me, might wind up with no life.

I think we're all going to need group therapy....

Saturday, August 9, 2008

Good News for California Homeschoolers

For those of you in the homeschooling world who haven't heard the news yet--especially those of you who homeschool in California--some very good news came out last Friday.

The California Second District Court of Appeal published its final decision on the In Re: Rachel L. case, which was the case that threatened to outlaw homeschooling for parents not possessing teaching credentials. According to my reading of this story from the L.A. Times, it looks like the court decided that the status quo--that parents are permitted to file the paperwork to establish private schools consisting of their own households--has been affirmed. And since state law does not require teaching credentials for private school teachers, the court affirmed that it doesn't require teaching credentials for homeschool parents who have done the paperwork to establish their private schools.

I was particularly struck by this passage the Times quoted from the decision:
It is important to recognize that it is not for us to consider, as a matter of policy, whether home schooling should be permitted in California. That job is for the Legislature. It is not the duty of the courts to make the law; we endeavor to interpret it...
Now, I happen to think that this judge gets it here--at least on this point. There are plenty of judges in this country who relish the chance to rule on policy.

However, while this is rightly considered a great victory for the homeschooling movement, I still think there are some storm clouds on the horizon. It's pretty obvious from some other quotes that the judge thinks the lack of homeschooling regulations in the law is a problem, and that the Legislature needs to address it. From the Times story:
"Our first task, interpreting the law of California, is made more difficult in this case by legislative inaction."

To that end, the court said additional requirements for home-schoolers in other states such as standardized testing or home visits should be considered by the California Legislature.
And you know, there are plenty of people in this state who are going to be chomping at the bit to get the Legislature to do just that. So continued vigilance on the part of homeschoolers is definitely called for. (Especially since Tonya and I--who between the two of us, have a Minor in Music, a Bachelors in History, a Bachelors in Computer Science, a Masters in Library science, a whole bunch of experience in our fields, and a whole bunch of other coursework in miscellaneous classes--have no intention at this time of going back to school to get credentials.)

And there's still an open question about those who homeschool under the umbrella-program paradigm, where parents enroll in a school that provides some minimum of oversight while the parents teach the curriculum at home. My understanding is that the litigants in the In Re: Rachel L. case were homeschooling under this arrangement.

(Quick background: in California, all children must attend public schools unless they meet one of three "exemptions:" they must either attend a private school, or they must have a credentialed tutor, or they must belong to a school that assigns the curriculum and does the testing, but allows the parents to teach the curriculum at home. Most homeschooling falls under the first of these: the parents file the paperwork to establish private schools. But there are a substantial number of homeschooling families that operate under the third of these exemptions. These are often called "umbrella" programs. One of the arguments in the In Re: Rachel L. case is that the Sunland Christian School, which administered their umbrella program, was allowing the Longs too much freedom, with not enough oversight, to be kosher under the law. This argument doesn't appear to have been decisively settled; the court that originally made that argument is now no longer involved with the Longs.)

Nevertheless, even with all the above caveats, this ruling is still good news.

A PDF file of the text of the decision, courtesy of the LA Times story, is here.

Friday, August 8, 2008

Calvin as a Teaching Tool? With Egyptians?

You know, it's weird how occasionally you'll start to see some theme, some concept, muscle its way into your life from many different unrelated directions at once.

Here's what I mean: you have a conversation with a family member about, say, Monarch Butterflies. And then, that evening, you flip on the TV to the Discovery Channel, and there's a show on about Monarch Butterflies. And then the next day, you go out in your yard to do some yardwork, and a Monarch Butterfly lands on your nose.

And you wonder whether the universe is trying to tell you something, and if so, what.

Well, our cosmic trajectory has just intersected with Calvin and Hobbes several times in the last few weeks, in ways that make us think that God is trying to tell us something. Could be worse, I suppose; he could have had our cosmic trajectory intersect with that of The Family Circle or something. And as much as I liked it, I'm not sure I'd want to start seeing in my life signs of The Far Side become immanent.


...


It started with the Pillowfight Fairy, as so many things do these days.

She has developed an absolute love of Calvin and Hobbes. And we have both The Complete Calvin and Hobbes--containing every strip ever written--and The Calvin and Hobbes Tenth Anniversary Book, which contains much of Bill Watterson's commentary on his creation. So the Fairy has been known to wander over to the bookshelf, pull out Volume One (which is almost as heavy as she is), hoist it up on the table, and read it for hours--to herself or to anyone who will listen, punctuated by fits of 5-year-old giggles.

And we've noticed something of a problem. For one thing, she has started sassing back to her Mommy and me in much the same way that Calvin does to his parents. Now we've tried explaining to her that much of the humor in C&H comes from the fact that Calvin says things that we all think, but would never say because it's completely inappropriate; but first-graders never listen to reason (as you'd think we'd understand, given how much Calvin and Hobbes we've read ourselves...). Calvin is not known for his tolerance of authority. So when the Fairy starts emulating him, Mommy and I start thinking: This. Ends. Now.

Furthermore, we've noticed certain new phrases entering the Fairy's vocabulary that we never taught her. I mean, when she declares over her dinner: "This stuff smells like bat barf!"; when she calls her siblings "Booger Brain"; when she tells her Daddy, "That's what you think, Bucko...." We know that we weren't the ones who taught her that.

That, and she keeps trying to transmogrify the Adrenaline Junkie into a slug.

So a funny thought crossed our minds. One of these days, we're going to introduce the Fairy to the wonders of Shakespeare. If she keeps this up, she'll wind up going around addressing everyone, "Thou vile pig-born strumpet!" or somesuch. And hopefully, those who are literate enough to understand her will be too amused to be insulted....

But for now, we figured we had to set some boundaries. So we banished Calvin and Hobbes for the rest of the month, and let her know that it was because she was starting to act a wee bit too much like him.


...


But like some kind of hideous alien zombie that keeps coming back even when you zap it, Calvin and Hobbes keeps popping back into our lives from weird dimensions. This next time, it sneaked up on us via the latest Carnival of Homeschooling. Barbara Frank submitted a post about the way that schools are depicted in C&H. Now, granted--the entire comic strip is written from Calvin's point of view; nevertheless, this post pointed out that there's not one positive depiction of school in the entire run of the comic strip. School is depicted as slavery, as torture, as something through which heroic adventurers demonstrate their heroism by escaping. Dramatically.

And Ms. Frank made the observation that C&H has become particularly beloved among homeschooling circles precisely because of its view of traditional, institutionalized schooling. Of course, it's a great comic strip for many other reasons; but given that many, many homeschoolers have had bad experiences with the public schools--either during their own childhoods, or with their own kids' schooling--the depiction of the schools in C&H resonates with many of them.

And it was also pointed out in the comments that Calvin and Hobbes is a great tool for teaching reading. It's funny, for everyone from the youngest kids up to the oldest grandparents, even though it uses really big words. You introduce young kids to it, and they will learn to read specifically so they can enjoy the humor in it.

(Incidentally, while I haven't been reporting on the Carnivals lately, there continues to be a lot of good stuff in them. This post is about the neurological processes associated with language and with reading, with a brief exploration of how this happens in Asperger's kids. And there are two posts, here and here, about the differences between gifted kids (and adults!) and their more "normal" peers, and how these differences need to be approached and handled. Gifted kids often have it tough, in many ways. This stuff is worth a look.)


...


Well, even though we banned Calvin for a month, the Fairy still has Calvin on the brain.

Wednesday we took a bunch of art supplies with us to the singing practice we were holding at Church. The idea was, of course, that Daddy would sing with the group (in preparation for Sunday's service), while the girls quietly, peaceably doodled.

(Of course, these ideas never quite work out as nicely as we hope. This may be related to the Fairy's affinity for Calvin, after all, but it doesn't explain the Adrenaline Junkie. She is explained by the fact that she's three....)

Well, one of the teen girls present was sketching out a profile of a very Manga-styled character, and was lettering a very stylized title for her creation down the side of the page. The Fairy saw this, and thought it was a great idea, so she pulled out her crayons and doodled....

Matching the layout of the Manga-inspired work of the other young lady. And then, before she ran out of time and we had to go home:
Yeah, she loves Calvin and Hobbes. I was pretty impressed, actually.


...


Now, in our homeschooling, we're following the scope and sequence recommended in The Well-Trained Mind, by Jessie Wise and Susan Wise Bauer. And in this sequence, History of the Ancient World is covered (the first time) in the First Grade. So the Fairy has been learning about the Ancient Egyptians now for the last couple of weeks (since we decided to start our school year in July). And today, Tonya read for her from a (very old) library book entitled The Art of Ancient Egypt. Now, Egyptian art was of course very stylized. The book mentioned that there were several rules that this art had to follow (particularly when depicting people with social status):
One rule was to paint a clear outline and fill in with color. Another was to paint the head and legs from the side, and the shoulders and eyes from the front. That is why you see parts of the front and side of the figure at the same time.
Very interesting, of course; but a bit abstract if you're only five. Tonya tried to have the Fairy narrate back what she had heard; but it hadn't stuck.

So Tonya had a sudden flash of genius. The best way to teach the rules of Egyptian art, is to make the Fairy do a picture (she loves drawing) in which she has to obey the rules of Egyptian art! And Tonya let the Fairy choose the subject of the portrait.

Guess whom she decided to draw in the Egyptian idiom?
Let's see... shoulders viewed from the front, check. Feet viewed from the side (pointing the same way), check. Head from the side view, check. Almond-shaped Eye, viewed from a frontal perspective, check. Hips and legs from the side, check. Strongly outlined, fully colored in, check.

I think she got it. This image is ready to go on the inside of a tomb, with Anubis balancing his heart on the scales before Osiris to see whether he's ready to enter the afterlife. (Although my foreboding tells me that something really weird is about to happen in the next frame....)

Anyway, to lock in the lesson, Tonya had the Fairy do a written narration. These are the instructions on how to do an Egyptian-style drawing, as understood by the Fairy:

(Side note: We are having the Fairy use lined paper with each capital letter about 1/2 inch tall. We started using the new size of paper when we began her first-grade year in July. Prior to this, the paper we used had lines spaced about twice as far apart, giving letters that were a full inch tall. We noticed that, the moment we started using this paper, her writing became much more neat, much more regular, and much prettier. We can only conclude that writing smaller letters, for one who has mastered basic pencil skills, is much easier than writing the big stuff. It's faster, too.)

Wednesday, August 6, 2008

The Enemy Is Us

Ok, I've been duly baited. In a post where he shares some good personal news, Roger Z takes a little digression and gives me a little shout-out:
First, a quick shout out to Chris and another hello to Tim- thanks Tim for blogging me I've now quadrupled my readership this month (you, Chris, and me... twice). Chris apparently lives down in the mountains of north Georgia, which I've been through once and are a beautiful, enchanting place, as is most of the southern Apps. Glad you stopped by and I'll be checking out your blog from time to time to make sure you're getting your economics straight. :)
Well Roger, just so happens that I've been mulling over some economic thoughts, so I think I should put them out here and let you grade them.


...


We've all been hit hard by the recent spike in fuel prices, and as has become traditional in our society, our first response to this--even before we try to find solutions--is to figure out whom to blame.

That's right! If we can find out who's behind this mess, who's benefiting from it, and just make them pay, we can get back in control of the situation with a just solution.

And it would appear that the favorite bogeyman in the present crisis is Big Oil. After all, the accusation goes, just look at the revenue they're bringing in! We're getting reamed at the pumps, and they're seeing record profits. Obviously they're profiteering, making a killing at our expense!

Now, they aren't the only targets. There's also Congress; and there are the oil speculators; and there's OPEC; and so on, and so on. But the oil companies seem to come in for the worst criticism.

Now, I'm going to say something that will probably make some of you think that I'm an idiot, or that I'm "In the Pockets of Big Oil" (as if--we could certainly use the money): Big Oil isn't the problem here.

We are.

That's right, we--those of us who use the gas, are the ones who (in the current circumstance) set the prices so high.

But before the flame war starts, let me go back to first principles and give an explanation.


...


Imagine a traditional auction. Say a long-lost Van Gogh has just been discovered in someone's attic, and the discoverer has taken it to Christie's to have it auctioned off. The thing sells for the ridiculously high price of seven million dollars.

First question: who's responsible for setting that ridiculously high price?

If you said "That greedy seller did," you owe me a kewpie doll. ;-)

The correct answer, of course, is that the price was set by the wealthiest and most desperate buyer. In a traditional auction, the would-be buyers are in fact competing with each other; whoever is willing and able to bid higher than all the others, is the one who sets the final sale price. And the more desperate the buyers are to win, the higher the bidding goes. In this instance, the seller is not responsible for setting the final sale price; the buyer offered to pay seven million dollars, and all the seller did was agree to the buyer's price.


...



Now imagine a commodities market. In a much-simplified sense, they should be considered two-way auctions: There are numerous sellers--oil production companies, oil export companies, government producers, and the like. And there are also numerous buyers--retail gas companies, refineries, militaries, manufacturers, etc.

The buyers are under pressure to secure the oil they need for their operations; after all, if they don't get everything they need, they may have to scale back operations and cede market share. They'd like to get a low price, obviously, but they may not be able to hold out long enough for those low prices, or they will get outbid by the other buyers and not secure the supplies they need.

There are two ways that a buyer can make a trade. A buyer can look at all the asking prices that the various sellers have posted for their product; and if the lowest asking price is low enough, the buyer can say, "I'll take it." Alternatively, the buyer can decide that none of the existing asking prices are good enough, and can post a lower bid, in hopes that some desperate seller will come along and accept it--which is by no means guaranteed.

The sellers are under pressure, as well. They have oil, but they need money. Now, they would obviously like to get the highest price they can, but if they set too high an asking price, they run the risk of being undercut by one of their competitors who's just a little more desperate to trade.

As with the buyer, there are two ways that a seller can make a trade. A seller can look at all the bids that the various buyers have posted; and if the highest bid is high enough, the seller can accept it. Alternatively, the seller can decide that the bids are all too low, and can post a higher asking price in hopes that some desperate buyer will come along--again, which is not guaranteed.

Thus, a two-way auction. The buyers are competing against each other for the supply. And this competition among the buyers tends to push the prices up, as each buyer has to top the others' bids in order to make the trade. Likewise, the sellers are competing against each other for the demand. And this competition among the sellers tends to push the prices down, as each seller has to undercut the others in order to make the trade.

So who determines the final sale price in a commodities market?

Answer: Whoever is most desperate to make the trade. If the buyer is more desperate than the seller, the buyer looks at the lowest available asking price--whatever it is--and says, "I'll take it." If the seller is more desperate than the buyer, the seller looks at the highest available bid--whatever it is, and says, "I'll take it."

So if you're trying to figure out which way the price of oil will go (which, according to the Efficient Market Hypothesis, is a fool's errand), what you would need to know is whether the Buyers or the Sellers are going to be more desperate to make the trade. If the buyers are more desperate, they will bid the prices up, as each tries to secure its own supply before the other guys get it all. If the sellers are more desperate--like they were in the mid-eighties, when Iran and Iraq were desperately flooding the market with oil to bring in the cash to finance their war efforts--they will start competing against each other on price, and the buyers can pick and choose among them, bringing the prices down.


...


Ok. So how do the prices work their way through to the pump? Well, it is the fear of every gas retail outlet that they will wind up running out, and have to place a "No Gas Today" sign on their pumps. Not only is that really bad PR, it winds up losing them both revenue and market share. So if they expect to sell x gallons, they must first secure a supply of x gallons (or the oil needed to make x gallons). That means, when supply is short in the markets, they must fight all the more desperately to get their supply.

Short supply causes desperation in the buyers; desperation in the buyers causes the price of oil to go up. This gets passed on to the end user--us.

If they can't get enough supply to meet their needs, they do the next best thing: they raise their prices even more. This, of course, drives some of their customers away to their competitors. It reduces their market share; but it also reduces the amount they have to supply, so it means they don't get to the point where they run out. And meanwhile, now the competitors have to figure out how to get that much more supply on the markets.

This, simply stated, is the first half of the law of supply and demand. When there is a glut, the buyers get to pick and choose whichever deal they want; the sellers are competing against each other, and this dynamic pushes the price down. When there is a shortage, the sellers get to pick and choose whichever deal they want; the buyers are competing against each other, and this dynamic pushes the price up.

The price of gas has gone up, because we the buyers are more desperate to buy than the oil producers are to sell. By competing against each other, we the consumers pushed the price up.


...


Now, the second half of the law of supply and demand is just as important as the first, but is often overlooked. It's this second half that makes the Free Market the most efficient form of economy ever developed by Man.

Those prices themselves cause changes in production and consumption patterns, that tend to eliminate both the gluts and the shortages--so long as well-intentioned politicians don't get in the way.

When a shortage causes prices to soar, as they have done over the last two years, two things happen. First, the consumers of the commodity--out of a desire for financial survival--try to figure out how to cut back, or how to utilize alternatives. In the case of gas prices, if they stay high enough for long enough, people start thinking about how they can get through their days while using less fuel. They start tuning up their cars and fully inflating the tires; they start catching rides from friends and carpooling instead of going alone; they run several errands in a row instead of lots of little ones; they walk and bike more; they use mass transit. If the prices stay high a bit longer, people start changing their car-buying habits--going with economy cars, or going diesel or hybrid. And if it goes on long enough, it can make alternative fuel sources attractive--such as fuels derived from coal, or algae, or natural gas. The net effect of all of this is to reduce the demand side of the equation, eliminating part of the shortage.

Second, the producers of the commodity are faced with huge profits, and a simultaneous opportunity to grab market share--so long as they can beat their competitors to market. The high prices give the producers both the money needed to expand their operations, and the motive to do so. It also gives producers of alternatives an opening; that is, if the big players can't or won't boost their production, occasionally alternate technologies come along that become very attractive. (I think of how the Cable monopolies, who were slow to respond to public upset about their service, wound up losing a huge chunk of their market share when regular satellite TV service came on the scene.) In the case of our current fuel woes, there are a bunch of alternate technologies on the horizon--from plug-in hybrids, to biodiesel, to coal-to-liquids technology--that will be ready to step in to the gap in just a couple of years if OPEC fails to see the light. Anyway, in sum: the high prices set processes in motion that increase the supply side of the equation, eliminating the other part of the shortage.

Given enough time, the high prices cause changes in both supply and demand that eliminate the shortage, which causes the prices to settle to a new equilibrium point.

(And a similar process works to eliminate gluts and excess capacity; if there's more on the market that is needed, the prices go down. This both spurs consumption and reduces production, until the glut is resolved; then the prices rise back to a new equilibrium point.)


...


So if we want to lower gas prices, how do we do it?

Basically, we have to make the consumers less desperate to trade than the producers. We have to get to the point that the producers are concerned about whether they'll be able to sell all their product at good prices, as opposed to the consumers being concerned about whether they'll be able to get what they need. To get the prices down, we have to get the producers trying to undercut each other again, instead of the consumers trying to outbid each other, like we have now.

And the way to do this? Supply and Demand.

On the demand side, this means doing those things that we all know we should be doing--conserving what fuel we can. Inflating our tires will help a little (though not as much as some famous politicians think); trip-linking will help some; carpooling; looking for more efficient vehicles; all of that will help.

Some. But I'm convinced that this isn't really enough. Our country is growing in population, after all. And we are competing for our oil against the massively growing economies of China and India, which are consuming ever-increasing quantities of the stuff. I think conservation is a good thing; but I don't think that our conservation efforts will be enough over time to supply our reasonable demands.

In the long term, I would certainly expect to see technological advances providing us alternatives to fossil fuels. We already have hybrids; soon we'll start to see plug-in hybrids which (for many of us commuters) will be able to reduce our gas consumption by an order of magnitude. Tesla Motors is out with an all-electric performance car. And there's been plenty of research lately into fuel cell technology. And then, there is all the research being done into cellulosic ethanol, coal-to-liquids, oil shale (which for the record Roger Z doesn't like), biodiesel, and a bunch of others. I see some combination of these eventually becoming standard in our transportation infrastructure.

But that won't happen immediately.

In the medium term, we've got to get more supply online. The good news is, we have enough resources within the US and off our coasts that we can at least make a decent-sized dent in our import needs, if we decide we really want to get at it. And given that the price of oil is highly non-linear, a decent-sized dent is probably all we really need to bring the price down to reasonable levels, at least until more long-term alternatives come online.


...


Here's the trouble. This was stated very eloquently by Robert A. Heinlein's character, Lazarus Long:
Throughout history, poverty is the normal condition of man. Advances which permit this norm to be exceeded — here and there, now and then — are the work of an extremely small minority, frequently despised, often condemned, and almost always opposed by all right-thinking people. Whenever this tiny minority is kept from creating, or (as sometimes happens) is driven out of a society, the people then slip back into abject poverty.

This is known as "bad luck."
While long-term high prices set in motion the structural changes that eliminate the shortages over the long term, they are very unpopular. This often causes us to look to our politicians to give us "solutions" that punish the "bad guys" (who aren't), ignore the underlying supply-and-demand problem, and short-circuit the solution the Free Market would bring us if only we would let it. As I said in my previous economics post:
The trouble is, these solutions are quite popular, precisely because they are intended to alleviate suffering. Politicians win elections by running on platforms containing these solutions. It is probably to be expected then, that long-term, continuous, unimpeded economic growth is likely to be rare in human affairs; there are too many incentives for people in power to do precisely those things that derail the train.
So the price goes up, and who do we blame? The Oil Companies! What do we do about it? Well, we need to teach them a lesson, and let them know that avarice does not pay! Especially when they are taking money out of the pockets of the little guy!

Well....

Turns out, the reason their profits are so high is not that the oil companies are charging so much; it's that they're selling so much product. They actually have quite modest profit margins, compared to many other industries, in part because they are the ones paying those exorbitant prices to import all that oil on our behalf:
In the first quarter of 2008, Big Oil had a profit margin of 7.4 percent. Over that same period, the pharmaceutical and medicine industry earned a 25.9 percent profit, the chemical industry earned 15.7 percent and the electronic equipment industry earned 12.1 percent.

...

Let's take a look at where each dollar spent at the pump goes. In the first quarter of 2008, the majority – 70 cents – was spent to purchase crude oil, 17 cents was spent on refining and retailing, and 13 cents on paying taxes.
Yeah, the oil companies are unpopular. But this is one of those cases where if we decide to punish them for their alleged perfidy--especially given that we are the ones who drove up the gas prices in the first place--it will be a textbook case of "biting the hand that feeds us". I think this cartoon has the right take on the whole thing....

If we really want the price to come down, the best thing Congress can do is open up federal lands for exploration and drilling. The worst thing Congress can do is demand its pound of flesh from the companies that will be doing this exploration and drilling.

It all comes back to Supply and Demand.

Sunday, August 3, 2008

Introducing the Next Backyard Project

Well, we decided that things had been a little too quiet around here lately.

[Insert sound of record scratching....]

Well, we decided that summer was wearing on, and there were some projects we needed to finish up in the backyard before the rainy season starts. So on Friday, we ordered twelve cubic yards of cedar bark.

Why so much? Well, we did a simple calculation: get a sense of the surface area that we want covered, multiply by three inches deep, convert your units properly (very important!), and pray that you didn't carry the two into the wrong column, or you'll wind up with enough bark to fill your yard up to your knees. Tonya's initial calculation would have done just that, by the way; it was high by at least a factor of three.

It was delivered on Saturday in a decent sized dump truck. Trouble is, the dump truck was too big to fit back into our RV pad; there's a roof overhang that just gets in the way. So we had the truck dump the stuff right in the middle of our driveway (and yes, we did think to move our cars out of the way first).

And then I started moving it. One... wheelbarrow-full... at... a... time....

My daughters had been watching a VeggieTales video earlier in the day. So when the Pillowfight Fairy came out and saw what I was doing, she remembered the moral message of the video and helpfully pointed out: "You need to use Perseverance."

No kidding. Ya think?

So what does twelve cubic yards look like? Well, this is slightly less than that:
That is not, as it would appear, a slightly obese Horta. That is my load of cedar chips, after I'd spent a good three or four hours (in hundred-five-degree heat) moving it, one barrow at a time, up our driveway. I had used Perseverence! And as a reward for exhibiting this virtue, by the time I was done I had an intensely crimson sunburn on both arms and my neck, I was covered with grit, dust, and sweat, my back and arms hurt (they still do), and my boogers were jet black.

Whoever said virtue is its own reward? ;-)

...

So, what are we going to do with this stuff?

Well, when we're done, much of our backyard planter areas will look something like this:
Under all that, Tonya first laid out some water-permeable ground-cloth, which hopefully will keep the weeds from getting too established. Then I dumped several loads of bark on it, and Tonya and the Fairy spread it out with rakes. The Fairy was being about as helpful as a five-year old can be; which is to say, the bark was getting shifted into big lumpy mounds. It probably would have been quicker for Mommy to do the raking by herself. But her help was still appreciated. We like getting the kids involved in work like this; the more we do it, the sooner we'll get to the point where the kids' help is actually helpful.

...

Of course, it was at this point that we discovered that the bark is much, much dirtier than the underlying, um... dirt. The moment the kids discovered the changes to their backyard, they were all over the stuff, and they came back inside a little later looking like coal miners. We suspect that it'll take a few good rainstorms to come along and wash the dust down to the ground, before the kids can play on it for three minutes without earning an automatic bath. And that big glandular Horta on the RV pad is just too much temptation to resist for anyone under the age of ten (and for a whole bunch of us above the age of ten too, I might add).

But it's a good kind of dirty.

And our backyard now smells like a cedar forest floor. I'll bet heaven smells like this. Without all that dust, of course. Or the black boogers....