Tuesday, March 11, 2008
Carnival of Homeschooling Up
The recent California court case is a big deal, and was featured in eight posts this time around, including my own entry.
There are a lot of other good things this week, including one that caught my eye here. The mother of this family is trying to keep her family integrated age-wise. They try to do things as a family, pushing back against society's tendency to segregate everyone into narrowly defined age-groups; but it's hard to do. She writes specifically about her wrestling with the fact that only one of her children was invited to a birthday party. Anyway, I've written about the issue of age-segregation in a theoretical way here, concluding that it is worth it for us to swim against the cultural stream; and I see in this blogger's real-life struggles a concrete example of what the struggle looks like at a practical level. She has my admiration.
Monday, March 10, 2008
Time to Indulge the Aerospace Geek In Me
Courtesy of the Instapundit, here's an excellently-written reminiscence by Major Brian Shul, who was the SR-71 pilot who performed the Battle Damage Assessment mission after our Libyan strike in April 1986. He talks about the plane, what it was like to fly it, and especially what it was like to fly wartime missions in it. Here's one sample I particularly liked:
One day, high above Arizona, we were monitoring the radio traffic of all the mortal airplanes below us. First, a Cessna pilot asked the air traffic controllers to check his ground speed. 'Ninety knots,' ATC replied. A twin Bonanza soon made the same request. 'One-twenty on the ground,' was the reply. To our surprise, a navy F-18 came over the radio with a ground speed check. I knew exactly what he was doing. Of course, he had a ground speed indicator in his cockpit, but he wanted to let all the bug-smashers in the valley know what real speed was 'Dusty 52, we show you at 525 on the ground,' ATC responded. The situation was too ripe. I heard the click of Walter's mike button in the rear seat. In his most innocent voice, Walter startled the controller by asking for a ground speed check from 81,000 feet, clearly above controlled airspace. In a cool, professional voice, the controller replied, 'Aspen 20, I show you at 1,742 knots on the ground.' We did not hear another transmission on that frequency all the way to the coast.On one mission, he wanted to get a really good look at the heavens, so he turned down the cockpit lights for a while. Here's a little of how he described it:
Where dark spaces in the sky had usually existed, there were now dense clusters of sparkling stars. Shooting stars flashed across the canvas every few seconds. It was like a fireworks display with no sound. I knew I had to get my eyes back on the instruments, and reluctantly I brought my attention back inside. To my surprise, with the cockp lighting still off, I could see every gauge, lit by starlight. In the plane's mirrors, I could see the eerie shine of my gold spacesuit incandescently illuminated in a celestial glow. I stole one last glance out the window. Despite our speed, we seemed still before the heavens, humbled in the radiance of a much greater power. For those few moments, I felt a part of something far more significant than anything we were doing in the plane.Yes, every aviation geek out there knows and likes that plane, so it's perhaps a bit cliche to pen yet another rhapsody to the glory of the SR-71. But it was a ship like no other. I've read reminiscences of awe-struck pilots flying down canyons of light, with the shifting curtains of the Aurora Borealis on each side. I've read reminiscences of pilots being scared to death, because they were throttling down and the plane nevertheless kept going faster and faster. I actually knew someone who worked on the plane, who had all kinds of memories of all the maintenance oddities that had to be strictly observed to keep the plane from self-detonating at those high speeds and temperatures--like, no fingerprints on the plane: the oil from your fingertips is flammable, if you get it hot enough. So was this old crew-dog pulling my leg? Quite possibly. But considering the weird stuff that we know for a fact did happen on that plane--like on that early Blackbird mission where all the electrical insulation burned off the wires, nearly causing a catastrophic condition--that I'm in no position to doubt anything the guy said.
The plane simply affected anyone who got near it. Yes it was weird; yes, it had its quirks; yes, it leaked fuel like a sieve (by design!) when the skin wasn't heated to 1100 degrees--but she still managed to inspire reverence that was nothing short of worshipful.
Oh, and if you're an aviation geek, and are ever passing through the Central Valley of California, there's one at the Castle Air Museum in Atwater, CA--about two hours south of Sacramento. This was only a few miles from where I lived when I was in high school. I remember when the Air Museum managed to score it; and then they moved it to a spot right by the road, where I nearly drove off into a ditch when I first saw it there.
So anyway, if you're at all into pilot stories (like I am), check out the linked article. I enjoyed it a lot.
Sunday, March 9, 2008
Important Disclaimer
One has to be careful when writing commentary on current events, if you ever decide to base an argument on the logic of the Declaration of Independence. After all, the Declaration was used by its drafters to justify an armed rebellion.
For the record: I am not attempting to justify an armed rebellion. I am not sending out a coded message to my legions of fans that it is time to start watering the tree of liberty with the blood of tyrants.
After all, right after Jefferson et al. wrote:
...That whenever any Form of Government becomes deſtructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to aboliſh it, and to inſtitute new Government, laying its foundation on ſuch principles and organizing its powers in ſuch form, as to them ſhall ſeem moſt likely to effect their Safety and Happineſs....they then went on to say:
Prudence, indeed, will dictate that Governments long eſtablished ſhould not be changed for light and tranſient cauſes; and accordingly all experience hath ſhewn that mankind are more diſposed to ſuffer, while evils are ſufferable than to right themſelves by aboliſhing the forms to which they are accuſtomed.Boy, howdy. Ain't that the truth.
My argument in my previous column is that parents have an unalienable right to raise their children according to the dictates of their consciences, and that this right includes the right to educate one's children as one seems best.
But note, should there be anyone confused on this point: I am not advocating violating any laws whatsoever. I am after all a Christian, and Romans 13:1-7 says:
Everyone must submit himself to the governing authorities, for there is no authority except that which God has established. The authorities that exist have been established by God. Consequently, he who rebels against the authority is rebelling against what God has instituted, and those who do so will bring judgment on themselves. For rulers hold no terror for those who do right, but for those who do wrong. Do you want to be free from fear of the one in authority? Then do what is right and he will commend you. For he is God's servant to do you good. But if you do wrong, be afraid, for he does not bear the sword for nothing. He is God's servant, an agent of wrath to bring punishment on the wrongdoer. Therefore, it is necessary to submit to the authorities, not only because of possible punishment but also because of conscience. This is also why you pay taxes, for the authorities are God's servants, who give their full time to governing. Give everyone what you owe him: If you owe taxes, pay taxes; if revenue, then revenue; if respect, then respect; if honor, then honor.Not to mention the fact that any violations of law on the part of homeschoolers would set back our cause in both law and in the public opinion.
We need to understand what our rights are, and (just as importantly) the theory of rights that underlies our government and legal system. And if and when the government engages in any violations, or starts treating the people as subjects instead of citizens, we need to call them on it.
But nothing I have written should be interpreted as a call to literal arms, nor as a call to general disobedience--civil or otherwise. So don't use my column as a justification to do anything ſtupid. I'm already feeling rebel enough after changing my own lawnmower batteries last week instead of letting an Authorized Service Center do it. ;-)
Again, if I knew for a fact that every reader of this blog was a logical, rational Man or Woman of Good Faith, I wouldn't consider this caveat necessary. But again, this is after all the internet....
Friday, March 7, 2008
Homeschooling & Constitutional Rights
Of the text of the In Re: Rachel L. decision, there are a couple of lines and paragraphs that have been particularly galling to the homeschooling community. The paragraph pointed out by Dana, which I excerpted in my previous post, is one of them. But the other big one is:
The trial court’s reason for declining to order public or private schooling for the children was its belief that parents have a constitutional right to school their children in their own home. However, California courts have held that under provisions in the Education Code, parents do not have a constitutional right to home school their children.Gabriel Malor at the Ace of Spades--who supports the right to homeschool--probes this point a little further.
Unfortunately, I'm not convinced that there is a constitutional right to homeschool one's children. So far I haven't seen a very convincing argument for it and for that reason I believe the best solution to this issue in California is legislative. On the off chance that someone wants to take up the challenge, here are my questions about a constitutional right to homeschooling:
(1) Who possesses that right, the child or the parents?
(2) Where in the U.S. Constitution (or, if you like, the California Constitution) can that right be found? EDITED: This would be more accurately phrased: "What part of the U.S. Constitution forbids the government from interfering with the right to homeschool?"
(3) If there is a constitutional right to homeschool, why isn't there a constitutional right to gay marriage?
(4) Is there a corollary constitutional right to not educate your child if that is your choice?
I've been pondering this question for a while. I'm not sure I want to tackle these questions directly, because I think they miss a deeper point about liberty.
Incidentally, while I've been contemplating this point and formulating my argument all day, waiting for my opportunity to write it out, the redoubtable Sunniemom went right on over to Ace of Spades and left a comment that stole much of my thunder:
The purpose of The Constitution (big T, big C)is to enumerate the powers of gov't, not the citizenry, and the rest is left up to states. Okey-dokey. But- do we sit around in our jammies waiting for someone to list all of our 'rights' before we get on with our lives, seeing as how none of us have the constitutional right to get in our cars and drive to McDonald's for a QP with cheese?Yeah--what she said.
Are we supposed to believe that families must have the state's permission to direct and determine the education of their children (uhm.. does this count potty training?), or practice their religion, or limit television viewing and computer games, or eat Fruit Loops for breakfast (considering the state does have a vested interest in the health of its citizens)?
BTW- when were judges granted the power to invent laws? Can we get Judge Croskey to do something about menopause and cellulite?
...
In the strictest sense, Malor is right: neither the US Constitution nor the California Constitution explicitly grant a right to homeschool. I subscribe to the textualist school of thought: the text of the law is a standard. The guys that wrote the law fought and argued over every word, including and and the, to make it say precisely what they wanted it to say--and the judges need to respect that. If the law doesn't say X, then X isn't in there; and when a judge sees X in there where it isn't, that judge is overstepping the bounds of his office and usurping the power of the legislature.
To be a constitutional right, it has to be explicitly listed in the Constitution. That is by definition.
But...
If you'll permit a brief excursion through First Principles, allow me to go back a little further and base an argument on the reasoning in the Declaration of Independence. Note that this is not strictly a legal document; rather, it is a work of political philosophy, giving moral and logical justification for America's defiance of Mother England. Here's a little passage that everyone needs to have memorized:
We hold theſe truths to be ſelf-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among theſe are Life, Liberty and the purſuit of Happineſs. — That to ſecure these rights, Governments are inſtituted among Men, deriving their juſt powers from the conſent of the governed....(I love the elongaged S. But longtime readers of this blog probably already guessed that, huh?)
The legal/philosophical dilemma faced by the Continental Congress was that their secession was illegal under the laws of Great Britain. On what basis could they justify doing something that was blatantly illegal?
Jefferson sets forth the argument here that the governments themselves are under authority. We have rights--natural rights--that do not come from any government, and cannot be removed by any government. In fact, governments exist for the very purpose of upholding these natural rights. Governments only retain their legitimate right to rule when they meet two conditions:
- They uphold the natural rights of Man, that inhere in us simply by virtue of the fact that we are human; and
- They operate with the consent of the governed.
Now as I mentioned, the Declaration isn't intended to be a document of law. Rather, it is something much more fundamental than that: it provides the philosophical foundation upon which the legitimacy of the law rests. The government described in our Constitution only has legitimacy because it passes the philosophical test raised by the Declaration.
So here's the one line takeaway: Government--including that defined by our Constitution--is only legitimate insofar as it protects our natural rights as humans. Jefferson, backed by the unanimous vote of the Continental Congress, said so; that's why we have our country today.
One ramification of this is that our rights exist prior to the Constitution. If the government managed to repeal the First Amendment, we would still have the right to free speech, since it didn't come from the Constitution in the first place. It's one of those unalienable rights that comes from our Creator, and any government that tries to take it away only delegitimizes itself. The Constitution didn't give us our natural rights. Our natural rights are pre-existing. Rather, the Constitution merely recognizes and defends them.
...
This is a good place to talk about enumerated vs. unenumerated rights, and enumerated vs. unenumerated powers. When the Constitution was originally written--before the adoption of the Bill of Rights--the general idea was that the powers of government were to be enumerated, and the rights of the people were to be unenumerated.
This meant that when the Constitution provided a list of powers belonging to Congress, those were intended to be all the powers belonging to Congress. So if something didn't show up in the list under Article I, Section 8, Congress didn't have the power to do it. And as written, this list is actually pretty restrictive.
In contrast to this, the rights of the People were to be unenumerated--that is, no list of rights was originally included in the Constitution. This was not because the people were without rights; rather, it was assumed that the people had the right to do anything that the law didn't specifically forbid. And even if a law tried to forbid it, that law first had to be justified as deriving legitimate authority from one of the Constitutionally enumerated powers; and even then, it couldn't violate one of the natural rights that the drafters of the Declaration asserted existed.
Now a controversy arose almost immediately with the new Constitution. The Anti-Federalists were very concerned about a lack of a Bill of Rights in the Constitution. They argued that unless the Constitution included a Bill of Rights explicitly declaring that we had rights to speech, the press, religions freedom, etc., these rights wouldn't have strong enough protection, and would eventually be devalued and discarded by Government.
The Federalists disagreed with this argument for two basic reasons:
- They believed that popular electoral pressure would be strong enough to keep the elected branches of government under control. The voters themselves would be the defenders of their rights.
- They believed that establishing a Bill of Rights in the Constitution would create an enumeration of rights. That is, people in power might be tempted to say, "Sorry--you're claiming a right that the Constitution doesn't actually grant you." Alternately, they believed that it might weaken the principle of enumerated powers: "Just as you have additional rights that aren't in the Bill of Rights, so too the Congress has additional powers that aren't in Article I Section 8."
But the second of these arguments is a bit more substantial. It was substantial enough that two Amendments were added to the Bill of Rights to try to keep the powers enumerated and rights unenumerated. The Ninth Amendment attempts to protect the unenumerated nature of our rights: "The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people." And the Tenth Amendment attempts to affirm that the Federal Government's powers remain strictly enumerated: "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people."
Sadly, these two Amendments seem to be ignored much of the time. If the Tenth Amendment were taken seriously, I don't think we'd have a Federal Department of Education today (or a bunch of other stuff).
And if the Ninth Amendment were taken seriously, questions like "Is there or isn't there a Constitutional right to homeschool?" would be utterly moot. The Ninth Amendment affirms that the Constitution doesn't list all our unalienable rights, and was never intended to.
...
So the big question isn't so much: Does the Constitution say we can homeschool? The question is rather: Is homeschooling one of those unalienable rights that Jefferson talked about? Does it perhaps fall under the "Liberty" part of "Life, Liberty, and the Purſuit of Happineſs"?
The case here is much stronger. It is pretty well accepted that the right of parents to raise their kids according to their own values, unmolested by the state, is a fundamental human right--excepting, of course, those cases where the parents are demonstrably incapable of caring for the needs of their children. But even here, it's not the parents' job to prove their competence; it's the government's responsibility to prove the opposite before it can intervene.
Note that this unalienable, natural right to raise one's kids is not listed in the Constitution, so it can't properly be called a Constitutional Right. But if the Feds went on to decide that the Commerce Clause (say) authorized them to dictate all aspects of child rearing--and systematically remove children from parents who didn't comply--we would recognize this as an abuse that would delegitimize the government, even if it was otherwise done in full compliance with the Constitution and with the consent of the courts.
What do the courts think of this line of reasoning? I suspect that most of them wouldn't go for it. But frankly--I say this as a free citizen of the United States of America, with full rights of speech and the press--I don't care. ;-)
But there are signs out there that at least some of the courts out have recognized the existence of the natural rights of parents to raise their children. There's been a lot of talk lately in the homeschooling community lately about the case Pierce v. Society of Sisters, because it contains this:
The fundamental theory of liberty upon which all governments in this Union repose excludes any general power of the State to standardize its children by forcing them to accept instruction from public teachers only. The child is not the mere creature of the State; those who nurture him and direct his destiny have the right, coupled with the high duty, to recognize and prepare him for additional obligations.The right to homeschool exists as an integral part of the right of parents to raise their children according to their own wisdom and the dictates of their own conscience. And this right didn't start recently--it didn't even start back in the '70's or '80's. It didn't even start with the Old Order Amish that were mentioned in the currently debated ruling. People have been training their own children in academics, citizenship, and morality since long before this nation was even founded--since the great civilizations of Greece and Rome, and even farther back to the days of Solomon ("Train up a child in the way he should go: and when he is old, he will not depart from it") and Moses ("You shall therefore impress these words of mine on your heart and on your soul; and you shall bind them as a sign on your hand, and they shall be as frontals on your forehead. You shall teach them to your sons, talking of them when you sit in your house and when you walk along the road and when you lie down and when you rise up").
I don't claim to have worked out all the legal ramifications. There are always those hard cases out there (you know, the ones that make bad law). And I do think the states have a legitimate interest in maintaining a well-educated population, and to that end have the authority to promote and regulate education. And there's no question that there may be natural limits to the right to homeschool, as there are for all other rights--not even the right of free speech is absolute, after all.
But all these are just wherefores and whereas's and ipso factos, that merely qualify the underlying truth: we have a right to educate our own children, which is as fundamental as our freedom of religion and our right of free association. And like these other rights, it does not come to us from the Constitution; it exists prior to the Constitution. It derives from the right to raise our own children, which is one of those unalienable rights of the sort that Jefferson talked about when he explained how it was that Britain had forfeit the right to rule us.
I realize this sounds pretty bellicose, but after all--three guys in robes may have just attempted to talk away the unalienable rights of a couple hundred thousand parents.
Thursday, March 6, 2008
That Court Case
About a week ago there was a court case decided by an Appellate Court of California that sent some shockwaves through the homeschooling community. The LA Times reported on it recently:
Parents who lack teaching credentials cannot educate their children at home, according to a state appellate court ruling that is sending waves of fear through California's home schooling families.This case wasn't on anyone's radar a week ago. The parents involved in this case hadn't contacted any of the homeschooling legal associations out there, and so none of them knew about it. Suddenly, out of nowhere, this ruling comes stating:
Advocates for the families vowed to appeal the decision to the state Supreme Court. Enforcement until then appears unlikely, but if the ruling stands, home-schooling supporters say California will have the most regressive law in the nation.
[The lower court's] reason for declining to order public or private schooling for the children was its belief that parents have a constitutional right to school their children in their own home. However, California courts have held that under provisions in the Education Code, parents do not have a constitutional right to home school their children. Thus, while the petition for extraordinary writ asserts that the trial court’s refusal to order attendance in a public or private school was an abuse of discretion, we find the refusal was actually an error of law. It is clear to us that enrollment and attendance in a public full-time day school is required by California law for minor children unless (1) the child is enrolled in a private full-time day school and actually attends that private school, (2) the child is tutored by a person holding a valid state teaching credential for the grade being taught, or (3) one of the other few statutory exemptions to compulsory public school attendance (Ed. Code, § 48220 et seq.) applies to the child. Because the parents in this case have not demonstrated that any of these exemptions apply to their children, we will grant the petition for extraordinary writ.When news of this got out and people started reading the decision, the first reaction of most in the homeschooling community was to read that and think: Omigosh, we've just had our rights taken away.
A few observers have looked at this ruling and come to slightly different conclusions. Ace of Spades says
The short version: The LA Times got it wrong in the first sentence of their article. Parents without teaching credentials can still educate their children at home under the various exemptions to mandatory public school enrollment provided in § 48220 et seq. of the Cal. Ed. Code. The parents in this case lost because they claimed that the students were enrolled in a charter school and that with minimal supervision from the school, the children were free to skip classes so the mother could teach them at home. There is no basis in law for that argument. If only the parents had attempted to homeschool their kids in one of the statutorily prescribed methods, they would have prevailed.What to think?
Well, here's the narrative, as I understand it. I'm writing this out partly to organize my thoughts (and perhaps inform those who know less than I do), and partly to see if anyone in my readership has a better idea than me, who'd be willing to comment and correct any misunderstandings I have.
The case, In Re: Rachel L, concerns a family with eight children, who've been homeschooling since 1987. This family has had many run-ins with child protective services; by all accounts the parents are very strict disciplinarians and are staunchly religious, and some of the older children have claimed abuse.
The family has been homeschooling under an odd arrangement: they are officially enrolled in a Sunland Christian School, which is actually a charter school--and thus a public school, although an odd one. The family had worked out an arrangement with the school that the parents would instruct the kids at home as they saw fit, and the school would send out someone periodically to check on them.
As I understand it California law mandates compulsory public education for all children ages 6 through 18, with a few well-defined exceptions:
- Children can attend private schools. Such private schools have to meet certain minimum legal requirements--primarily, they have to file annual affidavits establishing that they exist, listing how many students they will be instructing, providing background checks on the faculty, and so forth. These private schools are not required to have credentialed teachers; they merely need teachers who are "persons capable of teaching".
- Children can be taught by credentialed tutors. The tutors must possess a valid "Multiple Subject Teaching Credential".
- A student can be enrolled in a public school that supports independent study. A teacher at the school that assigns the curriculum and administers tests, but the actual instruction in the curriculum occurs at home by the parents.
The way that homeschooling is usually done in this state is through the first of these methods. A family intending to homeschool files an affidavit in the fall establishing an "unaccredited private school" with the parents listed as teachers (and administrators) and the family's children listed as the only students.
There aren't a whole lot that homeschool using the second of these exceptions as their basis. It's a whole lot easier to file the affidavit than it is to get a Multiple Subject Teaching Credential.
There are a fair number of people that go the third route (although there's an argument within the homeschooling community as to whether this should even be referred to as "homeschooling", since the parent isn't actually in control of the educational process; but that's an argument for a different time, place, and blog). I've known some students who've gone this route, and had good success with it.
Based on my very limited knowledge, it appears to me that the family at the center of the case was trying to use this third method--and was bending the rules to the breaking point. The Sunland Christian School is a public charter school, but was not actually in charge of the curriculum the family was using. Furthermore, the school had not listed in its charter that it would be allowing the independent study. So by the school's own rules, the children were truant.
And of course the family didn't qualify for the other two exceptions. I've seen no evidence that they attempted to establish themselves as a private school, by filing the proper affidavits; and the parents certainly didn't have the Multiple Subject Teaching Credential. So it appears that they may well in fact have been on the wrong side of the law.
And if that is the case, then it means that those homeschoolers who've done the paperwork, who've established themselves as unaccredited private schools, aren't going to be directly affected by this ruling.
This appears to be the view taken by Ace of Spades. And there are other bloggers out there who are cautioning level-headedness, too, like this one here. I'm leaning in that direction myself.
However...
There are still some things about this whole case that I find disturbing.
California has developed a reputation for being one of the most welcoming states for homeschooling. For the most part, all the parents need to do is file the affidavit, and they're in the pink. But: this arrangement is viewed by many as not much more than the exploitation of a loophole; and if that "loophole" were closed, California would go from being one of the
most welcoming states to one of the most repressive states overnight. Take a look, for instance, at what item 14 from the CDE FAQ page I linked to above says about it:
May a parent who is home schooling his or her own child file a Private School Affidavit?Translation: just because you've filed your affidavit, does not mean that the CDE has to let you homeschool your kids. As long as you fly under the radar, you're probably OK; but the moment that someone in power takes a disliking to you, the law gives you no guarantees. State law gives us no guarantee of our rights in this matter.Yes. A parent offering or providing private school instruction and who meets the requirements of EC Section 33190 may file an Affidavit in the manner described. However, filing such an Affidavit with the CDE does not constitute any opinion by the CDE as to whether a student enrolled in that school is exempt from public school attendance.
And Dana at Principled Discovery finds the following paragraph from the ruling ominous:
Additionally, the Turner court rejected, and noted that courts in other states also rejected, the notion that parents instructing their children at homes come within private full-time day school exemption in then section 16624 (now section 48222). The court stated that a simple reading of the statutes governing private schools and home instruction by private tutors shows the Legislature intended to distinguish the two, for if a private school includes a parent or a private tutor instructing a child at home, there would be no purpose in writing separate legislation for private instruction at home.Translation: the private school exemption in California law was never intended to apply to homeschools. That's why the Certified Tutor exemption is there....
(Quick comment on this: regardless of what the court thinks the Legislature intended, homeschoolers who file their affidavits to establish unaccredited private schools are still in full compliance with the text of the law. Courts should not be in the business of ruling against people who demonstrably are in compliance with what the law actually says.)
It's no secret that there are many people in this world who believe that homeschooling is, on balance, a bad thing, and would like to see it ended. Or they're willing to permit it, only so long as the parents get themselves teaching credentials first. (See Dana again for details on some of these assertions.) And where there are some homeschoolers who have been looking to the legislative process for relief--or to the ballot initiave process--I happen to think they're naive. The fact is, homeschooling is still widely seen as the province of antisocial weirdos. Any attempt to use the political process to establish the right to homeschool, at this point, would likely see us linked in the popular press with the Banita Jackses of the world.
...
Just for kicks, let's say for the moment that this court case heralds the end of homeschooling in California. What does that say about our society, about our system of government, that three unelected judges can--without any new laws being written, without debate in the elected legislatures--simply terminate the rights of hundreds of thousands of people in this way? I mean, if the whole society had a debate about how we were going to raise and educate our children, and this debate moved into the legislature (the elected representatives of the people) and eventually produced a restrictive law, that's one thing; but for this to happen out of the blue like this, with no public debate, in closed proceedings, by a panel of three non-elected officials? Perhaps I'm naive, but this seems to me a serious miscarriage of justice--not to mention a violation of the concept of Separation of Powers. Legislatures have the authority to pass laws only because they are accountable to us; in a democracy, the people get to decide what rules they are going to live under. Judges are there to figure how the laws apply in various situations, and to prescribe remedies when the laws have been broken; but they are not authorized to make new laws, because they are not elected by the people. The term "judicial law" is a bit of an oxymoron--or rather, it should be.
...
But in the long term, I think CA homeschoolers will be OK, if for no other reason than the fact that courts at the federal level appear to be sympathetic to homeschooling. The fact is, the status quo is on our side. The Supreme Court of the US has some long-standing rulings--such as the 1925 Pierce v. Society of Sisters--that while states can mandate compulsory schooling, they cannot mandate that the kids attend the public schools. While these rulings do not directly mention homeschooling, they created a legal climate in which homeschooling is implicitly supported, and states that attempted to ban the practice would likely find themselves struck down at the federal level. According to Wikipedia, Texas once tried to outlaw homeschooling, but lost the case in the federal courts.
Furthermore, the recent Morse v. Frederick "Bong Hits 4 Jesus" majority decision mentions homeschooling specifically: "If parents do not like the rules imposed by those schools... they can send their children to private schools or home school them..."
Also it's important to note that every homeschooling advocacy group and legal defense group in the country is on the case now, including HSLDA. Not to mention the fact that there are (according to the LA Times article) a minimum of 166000 homeschooled students in the state--and possibly many more, since it's really hard to count them; and then there are a good number of non-homeschoolers who are sympathetic. A more-or-less coordinated letter-writing/publicity/legal campaign could make a huge difference.
...
Whew. That's enough for one night. I will undoubtedly have further thoughts on this in the future. (I have further thoughts on this now; I just couldn't fit them all in...)
Wednesday, March 5, 2008
A Little Music From the Broke Period
Instead, I'll present you something I saw recently at Chris' site, A Mountain Homeschool.
(Note: a mild language warning applies.)
This is so funny because it's so true. The fact is, Baroque music did use a lot of the same chord progressions over and over again. It's part of the genius of these guys that it doesn't get boring; there's so much variation in melody, tempo, chord texture, and so forth that it's not always easy to tell they're using yet another manifestation of the Circle of Fifths, or of some other standard progression. And I wonder how the cello or bass players feel when they're playing something like Bach's Goldberg variations--the same ground line repeated over, and over, and over....
And yes, for all the alleged "transgressiveness" of modern music, it uses a lot of the same chord structures and other conventions--often without the musicians even realizing it. They think they're being new and original; in reality, they're merely speaking this same musical language Pachelbel, Bach, Vivaldi, and others developed three hundred years ago, just in a slightly different accent.
Anyway, this gave me a good laugh. I hope you enjoy it too. Maybe it'll help me be not so mad, so I can write something a little more coherent about that court case tomorrow.
Update: While further fooling around on youtube, I came across the following, which I figured I'd throw on for the fun of it. It's entitled "Pachelbel's Loose Canon".
Tuesday, March 4, 2008
Thoughts on the Passing of Gary Gygax
Now, I realize that I could probably write a post like this at least once a week. There's always someone noteworthy, someone worthy of respect and remembrance, passing on. I found myself wondering a week ago about whether I should write something about the passing of the great William F. Buckley. He was an institution, after all. He left such a mark on the political scene of this nation that had he not existed, it's fair to say politics in this country would have developed so differently that none of us would recognize it.
Of course, he was such a colorful character that the personal tributes that have been penned since his passing nearly always contain some off-the-wall anecdote. One personal recollection I read mentioned the fact that for someone with such a huge vocabulary and powerful wit, he was in fact a lousy Scrabble player. The comment was made that maybe this was because he was unaccustomed to speaking in words of eight letters or fewer.
Now, I'm not really the one to pen a tribute to William F. Buckley, not having been intimately acquainted with either the man or his work (aside from a brief subscription to National Review a few years back, which I decided to let lapse because I couldn't find the time to read it). For tributes, go to the National Review site--there are some very moving and insightful ones there.
But another man passed today for whom I can provide a tribute. If Buckley was the man responsible for introducing phrases like "Immanentizing the Eschaton" into the modern lexicon, today we mourn the passing of the man who introduced phrases like "Armor Class" and "Hit Points" and "Saving Throw", and who was responsible for introducing many a budding mathematician and engineer to the Platonic solids.
Gary Gygax, the creator of the Dungeons and Dragons role playing game franchise, passed on to "one of the Outer Planes" earlier today at age 69.
Yup. I was a D&D gamer back in my Junior High days.
(I can just hear all the astonished gasps from my readership...)
Of course, not long after its introduction the game quickly became associated with geekdom; those who played it were usually not considered the cool people. But you know? We didn't really care. The fact was, the game was fascinating. Most of us had developed a taste for fantasy literature--Tolkien, C.S. Lewis, Lloyd Alexander (the Prydain Chronicles), Terry Brooks (The Sword of Shannara, etc...), Piers Anthony, the list goes on. And what we found was that after reading and digesting one of these works, our imaginations would be lost in that world. These fantasy realms were so much more interesting than the mundane realm we inhabited--of grim and grey schools, where jocks and cheerleaders fancied themselves our betters, where the opportunity to do great things and be great people so rarely presented itself. After reading these books, we wanted to inhabit them; we wanted to walk the vale of Lorien, we wanted to lead a cavalry charge, we wanted to scale the side of Mount Doom, we wanted to pick the pocket of the corrupt nobleman and slink away into the shadows.
Gygax figured out a way to transport us into those worlds. We were no longer passive observers, merely reading about these great realms and wishing we could have been there; we could now participate. We could affect these worlds, and be affected by them; we could experience fear, and joy; we could act with wisdom, or with folly, and reap the consequences of our actions; we could display heroism, and face death. We did not merely read stories of bravery, heroism, or magnanimity; we got to live them.
And it should be noted that some of our number lost themselves so completely in the game that they never came out. It's not always easy to disengage the imagination. Occasionally one would hear of a player who became so despondent over the death of his character in the game, one that he'd been playing and developing for months or years, that he would commit suicide. This, of course, would be followed by parental campaigns to do away with the game. And there were questions raised from time to time about all the combat imagined in the game; there was lots of fighting of monsters--and of other people--involved, and that didn't sit well with certain segments of society. Furthermore, there were of course magical elements in the game, that caused concern among many Christian parents. Some of us felt a little like rebels for playing.
Rebel or not, though, I think it was actually good for most of us--especially considering the other things kids can get themselves into these days. At least we were there engaging our minds. The game helped some people with their reading and creative writing skills, with artistic skills, and even with math skills. All this was especially true for those who were the Dungeon Masters; they had to develop a scenario--including maps, placement of monsters and other challenges--and then keep track of a thousand little details as they acted as a neutral arbiters between the players and the challenges written into the scenario.
(And you have to admit, we adolescent boys who were deeply into Dungeons and Dragons were generally not engaging in underage sex.)
Truth be told, there were some difficulties that I and my brothers had with the game. For one thing, the game works best when you have at least five or six people, and we didn't often have that. During the time we were most interested in D&D, my family lived near Air Force bases in Germany. We would occasionally have the chance to get together with other Air Force brats to play a game, but mostly it was my two brothers and me--which really isn't enough to do it justice. And to do it right, you can't just play it occasionally--it has to be a regular commitment, so that everyone can see everyone else's characters grow and change in a fantasy world that has some continuity from one adventure to the next.
And then there are inevitable problems that result when your character dies unexpectedly. What do you do for the rest of the afternoon, while all your other friends are discussing strategies to sneak up on all those bugbears? We had a beginners' scenario once, where we all went in with newly-created Level 1 characters, and my thief fell into a pit in the very first room we entered and took enough hit-point damage from the fall to kill him. I spent the rest of the afternoon wandering around outside wishing some of my other friends would die so I could have someone to talk to.
So having a really good D&D campaign was difficult to arrange. You need lots of people who are willing to commit to showing up every time the group gets together; you need to have contingencies in case someone gets knocked out of the game too soon (like, will they meet any wandering strangers during the course of the game, that you can assign to the bereaved player?), you need a good, imaginative, and fair-yet-flexible Dungeon Master who's committed to a successful campaign (successful from the point of the players, not necessarily their characters--there's a difference). These things are not always all available, and as a result my D&D experiences were sometimes a little frustrating.
Nevertheless, I have many fond memories of playing the game, and I've often found myself in agreement with what this guy said:
Well, yes, there would be something awesome about it. Ain't going to happen anytime soon, but it'd still be awesome.Yet I've remained nostalgic about D&D. I still have a box, stashed away in the recesses of my basement, that holds a Player's Handbook, a Monster Manual, and, of course, the DMG with that big red monster on the cover. Duct tape is the only thing keeping these battered volumes together. Stuffed into the box with them are a collection of adventure modules, stacks of character sheets, and folders full of carefully drawn maps of cities, kingdoms, and worlds that have existed only in my imagination. It's a pretty big box, this one. And no — as I inform my wife every year or two — I won't get rid of it.
That's because I've long harbored a secret notion in the back of my mind: Wouldn't it be awesome to get a game going again?
There. I've said it. If you feel an urgent need to call me a big loser, I'm ready to take it like a man.
Anyone else out there have thoughts on Gygax or D&D, his +3 Gift to Geekdom, that you'd like to share? I'd love to hear about it.
Carnival of Homeschooling Is Up
My post about the Pillowfight Fairy trying to pull a fast one on Mommy is featured.
But on a more serious note, there are some posts there talking about legal and legislative threats being made against the institution of homeschooling in various places. This one and this one are both guaranteed to put typical homeschoolers in a really dark mood. Even as the practice of homeschooling gains traction within the broader society, there are plenty of people in positions of power who admit no benefit or legitimacy in the practice, and are willing to use their power to try to shut us down (either directly, or through Death by Bureaucracy).
The post I found most interesting is this one by Elisheva Hannah Levin, entitled Smoothing the Stones: Wrestling with the History of Education. It delves into the history of educational thought in this country--questions like, What philosophical ideas are currently dominant in the field of education in America? What is the purpose of education? What role do the schools play in society? What is the proper role of an educated person in society? She has an interesting perspective on this, having labored in the public schools for ten years as a teacher of gifted children and special needs children, and having an Asperger's Syndrome child of her own.
Anyway, there's much there that's worth a good read.
Sunday, March 2, 2008
What's On My Desk: Abandon Hope, Ye Who Enter Here
It occurs to me that these internet memes and "tagging" could eventually become the death of blogging as a phenomenon. Consider: someone starts a meme; it goes to five people, then twenty-five, then one hundred twenty-five, then six hundred twenty-five, then three thousand one hundred twenty-five... And pretty soon the whole internet is awash with lists of sordid things, and populated by people who've brought seven years' bad luck upon themselves because they ran out of people to tag to keep it going.
(Although I suspect that people who intentionally break the "Sordid" meme, like my dear sister-in-law, have thereby consigned themselves to seven years' good luck.)
Ahem.
So I've been exhorted to answer the question, "What's on your desk?" The rules:
You can tell a lot about a person by the state of their desk and what they keep on it. So, share what's on your desk. You can take pictures, take an inventory, or do both. Don't have a desk? That's okay, just give us a glimpse into the space where you pay bills, write letters, grade papers, study, or work on the computer.Well. I'm not so sure why Chris is so gung-ho about this, having done two full-length posts describing the contents of his work spaces in detail that would make Roseanne Roseannadanna proud. Not that I'm complaining, mind you; at least we've got him blogging again. ;-)
When you've finished your photos or inventory, post it on your blog and tag five more people to do the same. Don't forget to share the rules with those you tag and ask them to share their posts with you when they are done.
I, however, will not be quite so systematic. Here's the picture of the table where we have the Pillowfight Fairy do her craft projects, when she can actually find the table:
(Oh, by the way: that big sign to the right of the table was made by my older brother way back in his drama days; he had to make "flats", as they are called, in one of his set design classes. He let me snag it from him many moons ago. We'd put it in the dining room, but there's no available wall space there.)
And here's a picture of my lovely bride working at the computer. (Actually, in the original unedited photo, you can see that she's actually at the blogger.com website, writing this post.)
Nothing fancy about this. We've got a whole lot of junk piled up, but we've pushed as much of it away from the edge as we can so the Happy Boy can't get it and eat it.
Again, I'll not do a full inventory; but I will point out one thing. Notice that pink bin sitting under the light? The one that's sitting on a pile of homeschooling materials, which in turn are sitting on top of our scanner? Um... the family has been fighting off a bug the last two weeks or so, and there's been some tummy queasiness involved. We decided it was wise to keep a portable bin handy in case a sick girl on the sofa decided she couldn't make it to the bathroom in time. Note that, in case the need were to arise, we would grab the bin and take it to the girl, instead of bringing a nauseated girl over to where we keep the scanner and printer....
Anyway: regarding the tagging of five more people, I think I'll do my part to save the internet! Save the bloggers! and um... not. Especially not after inflicting all that sordidness on the people I love....
Saturday, March 1, 2008
Our Own Little Slice of Heaven
Today I got to see a side of my lovely bride that I hadn't yet seen much of. Oh, I knew it was there, all right; but this side of her hadn't really had chance to express itself since we've been married.
Regular readers of this blog will recall me making occasional comments about how I need to get the project done by the beginning of March, or I'll be in deep doodoo! The thing is, my wife is only one generation removed from her farmer's roots, and it shows. Her dad was raised on a farm in northern Alabama; her mother was raised on a farm in western Kentucky. And while Tonya herself wasn't raised on anything looking like a farm, she has always loved growing things. She babysat a pomegranate tree at her childhood home for many, many years, and kept it alive through a couple of transplantings (as they had to move the tree around during re-landscapings); she was heavily involved in maintaining the gardens they had.
And in the 7.7 years or so we've been married, she hasn't had the chance to do much honest-to-goodness gardening. For the first three years of our marriage we lived in a tiny shoebox-of-an-apartment in San Jose, and the only living green thing in our apartment was an overgrown potted vine (which has long since set its roots in that great rainforest in the sky). We moved here about four and a half years ago, but she hasn't had a good opportunity before now to have her garden. We were always doing some other project: planting new fruit trees, building terraces and walkways and a patio, pruning, working on the lawn, doing other projects indoors.
And truth be told, this place was a bit of a mess when we bought it; there was a lot of work to be done to get it into shape. This was especially true of the backyard, where previous renters had done automobile maintenance on their fleet. We've found a whole lot of weird debris back there as we've been digging and landscaping--everything from big lengths of chain, to what must have been an entire roll of nickles, to the bones of a cat that had been buried in a burlap sack, to (found today!) the two halves of a G.I. Joe action figure. Furthermore, most of the trees that were here on the property were in pretty bad shape when we moved in. We've lost nearly a dozen of our original trees; in their place, we've planted nearly twenty.
Part of the issue comes from the fact that our lot is a good-sized one. It's just a hair under three-tenths of an acre; but it's the corner lot in the development; and since our house is right next to the street, the lot is nearly all backyard. In fact, it was the backyard that sold us on the house in the first place. But in part because it's so big, it's taken us a long time to get it in order.
And it's been obvious for a while that Tonya missed being outside to play in the dirt.
So, as the Never-Ending Backyard Project began to wind to a close, Tonya started getting starry-eyed. She'd pull out a sheet of paper, draw a trapezoid in the rough shape of the area we had set aside for garden, and would start drawing stuff like this:
Mind you, this was only one of her diagrams, and an early one at that. Her later ones were labeled "Spring Garden", "Summer Garden", and the like, and were much neater than the above.
Now, the big thing preventing her from starting the garden was the fact that all the dirt I'd excavated while putting in the foundations of the walkway and patio was sitting there; and I needed much of that dirt for back-fill for when they were finally done. But I finished that project a couple of weeks ago. So, it was time to prepare the garden.
Yesterday I went out with a spade, dug up the rest of the dirt excavated in the patio/walkway project, and threw the big clods into a fairly even distribution over the garden-to-be, so that it wasn't piled up in one big lump.
Then, I mixed up a couple batches of Round-Up and doused all the weeds I could see in the garden, the orchard, and a couple of our planters. The weeds may still be green, but they're all going to be dead in about two weeks.
This morning I went out early and attacked the compost pile that's been getting bigger with every lawn-mowing for the last four years. I basically did with it what I did with the excess dirt: I threw it in a semi-even layer over the entire garden area.
Then, I pulled out the roto-tiller. I went for a couple of hours on that patch of ground, at progressively deeper and deeper depth settings. When I quit about lunchtime, there was at least four or five inches' worth of soft, tilled soil covering the entire garden. The dirt was positively fluffy.
Mommy was just finishing up giving the kids their lunches. I came in and reported what I had accomplished, and she asked me (with a smile on her face and an impatient sparkle in her eye) whether I thought she should go to the plant nursery first (to get seeds), or rake the garden level first. I suggested the former. Then she dumped the girls on me, grabbed the baby, and headed out.
Not long afterward she came back with nearly a dozen packets of seeds, put the baby down to sleep, and headed out.
When I went out to check on her, she'd pretty well raked that garden smooooooth....
When I went out to check on her an hour or so later, she'd used a hoe to draw lines into the dirt, outlining the zones of her garden in accordance with her latest "Spring Garden" diagram. She then carefully, systematically, began shaping the dirt into mounds and trenches:
She then proceeded to plant nearly everything that she got from the store. I watched this in a rather amused way: very happy about watching my lovely bride in her element, the way God intended her to be, and totally unwilling to tell her that four rows of cabbages is probably a little excessive. Warning to all my friends: Do not be surprised, in two months or so, if we try to give you a cabbage... or seven...
(Oh--and all the weeds in that picture? I hit them with Round-Up yesterday. They're all dead--they just don't know it yet.)
There's just something about a day like today that's satisfying. I do think of our yard as our own little slice of heaven, and every year it becomes more and more so. And especially after days like this, I'm a happy man.