Friday, February 8, 2008

Well, Maybe There's Another Explanation

I recently wrote this post that linked to an article by Kay Hymowitz in City Journal, about how societal changes are causing males to mature into men at later and later ages. The author specifically focused on marriage, and described the fact that men are choosing to get married later and later in life (if at all) as one of the signs of immaturity.

Boy, that article set off an absolute firestorm of protest, and I think the critics have some legitimate points--ones that we need to think about long and hard.

As part of the online response to Hymowitz, Dr. Helen Smith (whom I've linked to on several occasions before) wrote this column, in which she argues that one reason men aren't getting married as much--and the reason that they're pushing marriage off to later and later ages--is that our society has turned the institution of marriage into an absolutely lousy deal for men. She writes:
What Hymowitz misses is that men are on a marriage strike, not necessarily because they are perpetual adolescents or avoiding deep attachments to others but because the reward for being an adult in our society is so low, especially for men.

It’s really simple Psychology 101 (or Economics 101) — make something negative enough and people will avoid it, make it positive, and more people will engage in that particular behavior.

Nowadays, for many men, the negatives of marriage for men often outweigh the positives. Therefore, they engage in it less often. Not because they are bad, not because they are perpetual adolescents, but because they have weighed the pros and cons of marriage in a rational manner and found the institution to be lacking for them. It’s a sensible choice for some and the video games, magazines, and humor websites that Hymowitz disses are a way to fill one’s time with fun activities that don’t tell you that you suck, are an “unfinished person,” emotionally detached or on your way to jail for fake domestic violence charges. People used to treat men better than this.

Now, Atlas is shrugging...
Emphasis added by me.

This argument is followed by hundreds upon hundreds of comments, both at the linked article and at Dr. Helen's personal site. Reading these comments is quite eye-opening. In a very small nutshell, this is a summary of what many of them are saying:
  • Half of all marriages fail, and of the other half, you know that they're not all happy. The odds that a bride and groom at a randomly selected wedding will find long-term wedded bliss is less than half--perhaps significantly so.
  • Several of them cited statistics that 70% of all divorces are instituted by the women.
  • With the way family law and the family courts are constituted, men often wind up at the short end of any divorce proceeding. Kids go to the mother 90% of the time, even when the divorce happens because of her infidelity. Men also wind up paying alimony and child support quite frequently, at levels that literally reduce them to poverty.
  • Men are assigned the "irrefutable presumption of paternity" for any children born to their wives, even if the child was conceived by a different father. Even after a divorce--and even if the mother then marries the real father--the jilted husband winds up responsible for supporting the child up through adulthood.
  • If a woman makes a claim of abuse, the man will usually be required to stay away from her--and the house, kids, etc.--without any formal charges even being filed, let alone a trial held. Many commenters complained that this had happened to them or to close friends and relatives. They further claimed this has actually become a well-worn tactic by women to get extra leverage in the divorce courts.
  • Regarding the "immaturity" of (stereotypically) men's pastimes, the point was made that women's pastimes are often just as immature. After all, is watching TV for three hours a night any more mature than playing video games for three hours a night? At least with video games, the case can be made that they require some strategic thought. And they undeniably require more interaction than television.
  • And while one might make the case that scantily clad women, cyborgs, and exploding toilets are immature, a whole lot of the entertainment aimed at women--daytime TV, and women's magazines like Cosmopolitan, just to name a few--are every bit as immature. Scantily clad buxom women may fill the fantasies of men, but chick-flick dramas are filled with female fantasies about relationships that are no more realistic than men's fantasies. And in fact the female fantasies may be more damaging to relationships, since many women don't always realize that they are in fact unrealistic.
  • Women may say that they prefer sensitive, polite men--but the sensitive, polite men will tell you that they have a hard time getting women to notice them. Bad boys and jerks have no problem getting women to sleep with them; deferential, solicitous men get ignored. Several commenters mentioned that they intentionally turned themselves into jerks, treating women like dirt, so they could score--and that it worked.
  • Feminism holds as one of its core precepts that gender is purely a social construct--that males and females are psychologically the same at birth, and would remain the same were they to be raised in identical settings. The fact that men and women are different is seen as entirely due to environmental and social reasons. Furthermore, the traits normally associated with "maleness" are seen as defective and destructive abnormalities, rather than inherent (even beneficial) parts of men's personnae. This leads directly to the belief that men and maleness is bad, and men who like who they are are the worst of men; it also leads to women trying to remake men into something they aren't (and resenting it when their men won't change).
  • Men--especially husbands and fathers--are routinely lampooned in popular entertainment as being idiots, as being clueless, as being "emasculated" and unmanly. And this lampooning has seeped its way into popular culture. It is considered perfectly OK in some circles for women to run down men, in ways that would be considered chauvinistic or misogynistic if men were to do it to women.
  • The ways in which men relate to other men--which include, but are not limited to, sports and other shared struggles--are at best dismissed snarkily as "male bonding" by unsympathetic females, and at worst are derided as signs of residual immaturity that the men need to get over before the women will respect them as "grown ups". No thought is given to the possibility that men need this kind of interaction with each other, and that they benefit mightily from it.
  • Women change after marriage. Many commenters described how they married smart, principled, sexy, playful, libidinous, interesting young women who then turned utterly cold, shrewish, and cruel after a few years of marriage. These commenters concluded that it isn't really possible to determine how well a marriage will go by evaluating the dating period with one; even if a woman is good now, there's no guarantee she will be in ten years.
Now, at one level on can argue the truth of the above accusations. After all, Dr. Helen's commenters are obviously a self-selected group, and have a high percentage of people who've had some very bad experiences with women. They're not all objective. There may be some embellishment.

But regardless of whether the accusations are true (and for the record, I do think there's a good deal of truth on that list), it is important to note that a whole lot of men believe it. Many of the older commenters, citing the above list and giving the reasons that lead to their many divorces, declared that they are through looking for love. Women are just too much trouble. Many of the married ones said that they're doing OK, but that if something happened to their wives, they'd think long and hard before they started up again. Many of the younger men said that they had no problem dating women, but would consider it utterly foolish to wed one; that a woman as a whole might be fun now but the risks (especially the financial) were way too high to justify marrying.

There was just this resignation that men give up a whole lot of rights when they choose to marry, and they take on huge risks; that, given the dismal chances of the marriage succeeding, the theoretical benefits that might come from marriage simply aren't enough to justify it.

Thus, a marriage strike on the part of men. And from all accounts I've seen, this strike is growing pretty rapidly in our society.

...

Now, I'm a Christian who believes that God wanted for us to be celibate until marriage, and then faithful to our spouses until death. And I also believe that a healthy marriage is the best environment in which to raise children, which are of course a society's next generation. I believe that a society's mores regarding sex, marriage, and childrearing have a huge impact on the future trajectory of that society; and when a society gets these things wrong, it can self-destruct. This has happened periodically to other societies throughout history.

Given all this, I have two observations:
  • The marriage strike appears to me a rational response to a very unhealthy set of circumstances in our society.
  • If it's true, this is bad, bad news for American civilization. I don't think it's possible to read through the comments Dr. Helen got without becoming really concerned about the future our children will inherit.
I've got three kids; I want them to find good mates, should they desire that when they get to be the right age. I'm not sure those mates will be there. And the odd thing is, I'm at least as worried about the Happy Boy finding a good mate as I am about the girls--if not more so. In a few decades women may have a hard time finding good men; but I'm acutely aware of the fact that we men have a hard time judging the good character of a woman when our hormones are running amok. The most attractive women are not necessarily the ones that are best for us. A pretty face, a sweet smile, and a pleasant demeanor may make us think a girl is innocent and upright--even when her heart is utterly black. And if the Happy Boy grows up to be a handsome, self-confident young man in the time of a marriage strike, he's going to have lots of opportunities to make some very bad decisions.

Every day, I consider myself more and more thankful that God put Tonya in my life--and that I didn't marry some of the other beautiful young ladies I dated. Geez, it gives me a shudder just thinking about it. But I suspect that if something horrible were to happen to her, and I wound up alone or as a single father, I'd seriously consider keeping myself off the market--at least until the kids were grown. The chances of making a mistake are too high, and the consequences of such mistakes are too severe.

Wednesday, February 6, 2008

Concerning Violent Toys and Violent Play

Earlier today I got a comment from The Not Quite Crunchy Parent that read, in part:
...love to get some male input on a post I have up today on European war toys - your DS isn't quite old enough yet but the day will come...
So I decided to go over to her site and take a look. The post she's referring to is here. Basically, the post mentions an interesting parental phenomenon: European toymakers (including Lego and Playmobil) tend not to produce as many militaristic toys as do those toymakers that primarily serve the US market. And what militaristic toys do show up in European stores, tend to consist primarily of ancient and medieval weaponry, as opposed to modern tanks, guns, fighter jets, and so forth. Apparently there isn't nearly the demand in Europe for toys based on modern weapons than there is in the US.

And an interesting conversation started up in the comments (which, as of this writing, were written entirely by moms): why is it that boys go for these things anyway? Is it a question of honor and chivalry, or is it more about power? Is ancient weaponry more "manly" than modern weaponry, and do toys based on the former spur the imagination better?

Thus, the desire for some male input, and the comment posted to my blog. Hey, you're a guy--could you explain this guy thing to me? I'm honored, but I feel a little like a lab specimen. ;)

First, do I let my daughters play with military toys? Just so everyone is clear:

And no, I don't let the Happy boy play with these things. We're rather proud of the fact we made them ourselves, and he'd eat them. Maybe when he gets a little older....

Also, check out this post and this post. These aren't so much about toys for the little ones: they're more about toys for us big ones. But you know if I could interest my girls in siege engines and chainmail, I'd be a happy guy. (And most likely, so would their future boyfriends and husbands. Hmmm... Maybe I need to get some guns too.)

...

Now that I've established my man card, on to the more serious points.

A few months back I wrote a post entitled On the Seriousness of Children's Literature, in which I mused about how the stories that parents used to read to their kids were full of really horrible stuff--witches sticking boys and girls in their ovens; trolls, ogres, dragons, ghosts, goblins; people getting their heads chopped off; that sort of thing. (Take a look at any of the Brothers Grimm stuff--original versions--to see what I mean.) My thought was that perhaps these stories were not macabre merely because of some dark obsession on the part of the authors, but because these stories played an important social role: they helped children find their way in the world, by illustrating to them the virtues they would need to survive--and by pointing out what can go wrong when these virtues are not possessed. The purpose in any particular culture of its indigenous fairy stories, legends, and epic poems, is to prepare people for the world they are going to inhabit--and until recent times, that world had some really unpleasant stuff going on (wars, famine, disease, crushing poverty).

I got a commenter to that post who linked to an interview on Salon.com entitled A Game Called Suicide. This interview took the same tack, with children's play. It's pretty well recognized that play is a major way that children learn how the world works. Through running, climbing, and jumping, little bodies become stronger, they learn better balance, they become more dexterous, and they learn their limits (can I jump that far?). And this is not just true with physical play; imaginative play develops the mind and the social skills in much the same way. When you see kids playing kitchen, preparing imaginary food and serving it on imaginary plates to their siblings (and to their imaginary friends), they are actually learning, not merely goofing off.

And I happen to believe that this behavior is hard-wired into children. Their brains are designed to figure out where they belong in society, and to start practicing the skills necessary to survive and thrive in their intended roles. For example, my daughters are at the age where they often want to be in the kitchen, "helping" with the preparation of dinner. Of course, usually it's not exactly help--it would be quicker for us just to banish the kids to a different room and do the work ourselves. But it's good for the kids to be in there, carrying out what tasks they are capable of, and being shown how to do the tasks they're not quite capable of yet. Often they will observe things they don't understand, but then go into their rooms and "prepare" some "food" on their own. (Some of the recipes they come up with are quite a hoot, although not particularly appetizing to the adult imagination.)

The Salon article basically made the point that violent play--usually done by boys, but not always--falls along these lines. Like it or not, men have been the warriors in society in the vast majority of circumstances throughout history. And this doesn't only come out in the form of war; men have often been called upon to provide for and protect their families. And men today still have to compete for mates, compete for jobs, compete in lots of ways.

(I realize that, according to the feminist ideal, women are every bit as capable as doing this as men are. And I'm certainly not going to deny that there are some very tough women out there who are more than capable of holding their own. However, there is a social expectation on men in this regard that isn't necessarily applied to women. A woman may choose to reject the traditional women's roles and compete in the marketplace, and be honored for that decision; but men are expected to compete in the marketplace, and often lose the respect of their peers if they don't. But all this is getting off topic.)

I believe that playing war, and playfighting (cops and robbers, cowboys and Indians) is valuable, in precisely the same way that any form of play is valuable. It helps the kids gain an understanding of their place in the world; it helps kids act out (and thereby understand) the concepts of courage and cowardice; it helps kids learn strategy and situational awareness; it helps kids learn limits; it helps kids learn magnanimity. Many women have remarked upon the seemingly strange phenomenon of boys who fight like dogs one minute, but are best of friends the next; I think it's entirely possible that this comes about because the boys, through their violent play, have learned something of control and magnanimity and limits.

One other point, also raised by the Salon article: kids below a certain age tend not to do abstract verbal reasoning very well. This is the reason that Classical Homeschooling doesn't start the Logic phase before about age 10. If something traumatic happens in the world or in one's life--say, the September 11 attacks or a school shooting--we adults can talk about it and commiserate: What do you think of that? How could this happen? What do you think we should do about it? Now these events affect the young ones every bit as much as they do adults, but the young ones aren't yet mature enough to internalize and understand them through conversational methods, which require such abstract verbal reasoning. Instead, it is absolutely natural for the young ones to play-act. That is simply how they learn and understand.

...

So given that I'm not opposed to some level of violent play-acting, and that I feel it can be useful as an educational tool in the right circumstances, what do I think of militaristic toys?

Well, first thing--I think toy manufacturers are the spawn of the Devil, for the most part. ;)

(Aside from Legos, which are just cool.)

Of course, this opinion may be colored by the fact that we just got through another Christmas/Birthday season in our household, and we now have several dozen more blinking, flashing, beeping objects that we have to find places for (and hope that our kids won't play with today, please pretty please?).

And I do tend to think that the more a child engages his or her imagination, the better. Yes, a kid can play cowboys and Indians with a real-looking Colt .45 toy, but if one of those is lacking, it's entirely possible to substitute something made of Legos, or even a half-naked Barbie. Boys who want to play these games will not be discouraged by a lack of period replicas.

There may be times when having really accurate toys is called for. I remember putting together plastic models of airplanes when I was a kid, and the accuracy of the model was actually a good thing: I could ask my Dad (who was an Air Force officer) what this little bump was, and he might tell me that it was an antenna blister or a landing light or something. But I was a bit older by this point; and what interest I had in accuracy could have been seen by that point as an educational opportunity. For the younger kids, I can't see my wife and I fussing about getting the latest and greatest GI Joe for the sake of it.

And my wife and I loathe most licensed characters and toy lines. (We're not even really that enthused about Sesame Street.) I can't see us indulging a boy's desire to get into, say, The Transformers! Collect All Fifty-Two! No.

But if our son eventually becomes interested in ballistics, and decides one day to start making the projects in this book (or better yet, this one), I am so there.

...

As for the last question they asked: is there something more appealing, more manly, about the ancient warfare than there is about the modern sort? I personally think there is. I note that the honor guards of our modern military forces still use sabers. And I notice the affection that attends Old Ironsides, the USS Constitution. There's just something more romantic about them; in comparison, modern weaponry seems soulless. And the kind of warfare in which one side dies without ever seeing the foe, where the other side wins without ever having to match strength against strength, lacks much of the romance of the warfare of earlier ages. A one-on-one challenge between champions has romance to it; modern warfare tries to avoid the one-on-one challenge as much as possible.

Important note: I say none of this to denigrate the work that our current men and women in uniform are doing in Afghanistan and Iraq. I have nothing but awe and respect for the work they are doing over there, and I wish them nothing but speedy success against their enemies and a triumphant return home.

But even though modern warfare lacks the romance, and--indeed--is quite horrible, I still don't have a problem with kids pretending to be fighter pilots or tank drivers or ground-pounders. I think all of the previous arguments made above still apply; the kids who play this way are at some level trying to understand the way war works, so they won't be completely unprepared emotionally if and when it becomes their turn to defend their homeland.

...

So when the Happy Boy gets a little older, and starts running around the playground with all the other boys who are playing Monster, I'll not stop him. I'll make sure he knows when to back off, and try to keep him from bowling over the younger kids; and I'll darn well do my best to make sure he recognizes a chivalrous responsibility to defend the small and weak from whichever boy is the roaring beast of the moment. And I'll even let him do his defense with whatever "weapon" comes to hand and to mind, so long as he uses it honorably (no shooting in the back; no attacking an unarmed opponent, save the women and children, etc).

And if anyone takes offense, well... that'll be their problem.

Tuesday, February 5, 2008

More Light Reading

Back in December, I posted a list of books that my kids like. Or rather, I posted a list of books that my kids liked to pull off of the bookshelves when they were toddlers. And we tried to glean insight into their personalities and future careers based on their literary choices. As you may recall, my toddlers' tastes ranged from hardcore theological interpretation, to college-level physics, to home improvement. This, of course, made Mommy and me very, very proud.

Well, Mommy has been pushing the project for some time now of rearranging all the furniture in the house, as our wives are wont to do from time to time. And as part of this process we've been winnowing and rearranging the books on our bookshelves. We have a lot of books; and frankly, we've used up most available wall space in our house. If we want new books, we've got to get rid of some of the old simply to make room. And of course, my wife is a former librarian--so when she starts rearranging the books, watch out.

(Of course, with Tonya all our books tend to wind up in Dewey Decimal order. She's funny that way.)

So now all the books are in different locations. And now the Happy Boy isn't quite tall enough to get at the home improvement book, so today he had to pick out something new.

I'm very, very, very proud of his new selection.

Although... he may have to wait a while for his voice to change.

Carnival of Homeschooling Is Up

This week's Carnival of Homeschooling is up at About Homeschooling. My post Humbled by the Power of our Girl's Memory is featured there.

There's an excellent post by Elisheva Hannah Levin entitled Just Thinking about Inclusion and Ideology. She's been giving some thought lately to the issues involved in educating kids with special needs (about which she has first-person experience, as she's raising a son with Asperger's Syndrome), and the trends in mainstream educational thought on these issues. The post itself is very interesting, and many of the comments are too--for example, they discuss at length what would happen if our schools tried dividing up our kids by ability level instead of by age-determined grade level.

Check it out.

Monday, February 4, 2008

Yeah, But At Least I'm Not A Slav*

So, um... I found this quiz online that tells you which of the Seven Deadly Sins you're most like. Guess which one I tested as?



Wait for it...



Wait for it....









Which of the Seven Deadly Sins Are You?




Sloth -- All you ever think about is comfort, don't you?
Take this quiz!








Quizilla |
Join

| Make A Quiz | More Quizzes | Grab Code



Big ol' hat tip to Professor Glenn "Lust" Reynolds and his lovely wife, Dr. Helen "Pride" Smith.



*--in case you're new to this blog, the title is a reference to a little something I wrote a few days back, completely coincidentally.

Sunday, February 3, 2008

Humbled By the Power of Our Girl's Memory

It's become something of a cliché that the more experienced you become at parenting, the less you realize you know. Young couples who haven't had kids yet think they have a sense of what they're going to do when the first little one comes; then when there's actually a little squirming thing right there, and I'm supposed to figure out how to feed it, and hold it, and nurture it... well, the pre-conceived notions tend to fly right out the window. Yep, this happened to us too.

And it's amazing: as we parents gain more experience, we get tempted into complacency. Ok, we say, we've started to get a hang of things. We understand what's going on now. Now we can start setting up a system so we can get our lives back in order! Of course, then the wee one hits a new milestone, or enters a new phase, and we parents are back to realizing just how little we know.

By the time our kids finish the teen years, we finally realize we don't know squat. ;-)

So what prompted this observation?

Well, we've been including some memory work in the homeschooling curriculum we've been following with the Pillowfight Fairy. We believe that it's a very good thing for kids to learn how to memorize, in general; it's good for a person to be able to draw on a wide store of knowledge: poetry, scripture, important literary passages and dramatic soliloquies, and so forth. With the Fairy, we've been having her systematically memorize (among other things) the Bible verses she's been assigned in her Sunday School classes. A few weeks back, the teacher in her class handed out a sheet with five verses that the kids needed to learn; when completed, the kids earn a prize.

Now, when I was a kid, I did very well with the memory work I was assigned. My Dad had a method that proved to be pretty much foolproof: simply read the passage, out loud, eight times a day for a week. I discovered that every time I did this I had the passage memorized by the following Sunday. So it seemed the most natural thing in the world, that when I had children of my own who needed to memorize things, I would pass on this nugget of paternal wisdom, just as my Dad had with me.

I had it all figured out, you see.

Well. As is the case with many homeschooling families, in my family it's the mother directing the education while the father is away at work. And Tonya had been reporting for some time that the Pillowfight Fairy wasn't doing too well on her memory work. One day she would say, "Yeah, we worked on it a little today, but we didn't do too much." On another day she would say, "We didn't do the memory work today. [The Fairy] really didn't want to do it."

And I would grouse to myself about it. I know better than to jump all over my wife for not following the plan--after all, if it was me trying to do the schooling, I'd be lost. She knows how everything is going a whole lot better than I do, because she does it every day. Nevertheless, I would think to myself: Come on! Just read it eight times a day--what's so hard about that? And why are you letting the kid set the rules around here? Who's the boss?

This week, they went the entire week without touching the memory verses!

And in her class today, the Fairy recited all five of them, and was able to explain what they meant.

Um...

Hmmm. I'm not so sure what this means. I certainly didn't expect that. And my wife didn't either. What's going on?

So we sat around tonight commiserating, trying to figure out what went right. Here's what we figure. First, the Fairy has always had a way with language. And she loves memorizing poetry. If you ever meet her, ask her to recite Lewis Carroll's Jabberwocky to you. We think part of her success just comes from natural talent and interest on her part.

But there's more, too. Tonya explained that she's been trying to get a sense of when to push, and when to back off. Obviously we'd love it if our little girl worked really, really hard on all her work every time she sat down with her books. But given that she's human, we have to figure out what to do when she's just not in the right frame of mind. One possibility--which we tend to use with her math work and her writing skills--is to make her do it anyway, whether she wants to or not. And she does it, although she makes quite sure we know when she doesn't feel happy about it.




It should be noted that when we do push, it's generally only on those topics where progress is made through constant practice. There are just some skills that start to degrade if they're not used continually. Judging from our experience with the Fairy, this appears to be true of writing and math--if we miss several days, we have to spend a whole lot of time and energy just getting back up to where we were.

But at other times we try to take a more lenient approach--especially with those subjects that we know the Fairy is good at and likes doing. In these cases we feel it's important to not squash off her enjoyment of the subject matter. So with the memorization, Tonya has been careful only to make the Fairy do what she's inclined to at the moment. This is, of course, an important feature of the Charlotte Mason approach, and of the various "child-centered" approaches out there. And in the case of memorization (and, it appears, of our piano lessons as well), it really does appear that we can teach her effectively with a very light touch.

Of course, there's another concern that I have, that we haven't ruled out yet: when I was in school, I was good enough at memorizing and regurgitating my lessons that I could get decent grades without learning decent study habits. By high school, I could whip out a decent essay while the second period teacher's back was turned, so I had something to turn in at the beginning of third period. Great skill to have! It'll get you through high school. It won't get you through college, alas. It may be that the Fairy is so good at memorizing that she doesn't have to work at it--meaning she'll never learn how to memorize longer and more difficult passages, like Shakespearean roles. Of course, I could just be borrowing trouble from tomorrow with all this pondering. But the point is, I don't know.

I'd love to be able to refine our experiences into a generalized rule from which all homeschoolers could benefit. But alas, I don't think that's possible here. In fact, this is one of those pre-concieved notions that we threw out the window after trying to apply it to a real, live human being. When must we be strict, and when can we use the light touch? Um... whenever it feels right to use one method or the other. And I suspect it's totally different for each student. Not only that, I suspect it's totally different for each teacher.

Saturday, February 2, 2008

An Internet "Meme" (Sigh....)

So Chris from A Mountain Homeschool tagged me for an internet meme, and I thought that I'd go ahead and actually do it. Now for the record, I'm not much the kind of person who does these things. When I get emails from friends with heart-tugging inspirational stories that end, "Forward this on to everyone you know!" my typical response is to skim the email, then click duhhhhhh-Lete!

I suspect this kind of anti-social attitude explains in part my lousy performance in this last year's Homeschooling Bloggers Awards.

Nevertheless, here are the rules of this particular meme:
1. Pick up the nearest book (of at least 123 pages).

2. Open the book to page 123.

3. Find the fifth sentence.

4. Post the next three sentences.

5. Tag five people.
So what book am I reading?

If this meme had come around last year at this time, I could have done a whole bunch of really good ones: I had just gone through C.S. Lewis' The Problem of Pain, Sun Tzu's The Art of War, and Niccolo Machiavelli's The Prince--not to mention the entire Chronicles of Narnia series.

Alas, this year things have gotten pretty busy, and I haven't been able to read as much for personal pleasure or edification. I suppose I could throw in something from Drawing with Children by Mona Brookes or The Well-Educated Mind by Susan Wise Bauer, but I haven't exactly been reading them very faithfully.

So, I'll have to include a passage from the book I'm reading to the Pillowfight Fairy: E.B. White's The Trumpet of the Swan. Page 123, fifth through seventh (complete) sentences:
When the skunk wandered close to the building, Sam reached over, dangled the noose in front of the skunk, slipped the noose around the can, and gave a jerk. The noose tightened, and the can came off. As it did so, the skunk turned around and squirted--right at Mr. Brickle, who jumped back, stumbled, and fell.
Hm. That was actually a pretty good one. These three sentences actually tell something of a story all by themselves. With this kind of random pick-a-sentence-by-formula, it's not unlikely that you'll get something pretty boring, along the lines of:
"What did you say?" he said.

"Oh, nothing."

For the next few moments they just sat there.
The passage from Trumpet of the Swan actually makes you want to know what happened in the rest of the story. Incidentally, we haven't gotten to that part of the story yet, so it's made me a little curious to know what comes next.

As for the bit about tagging five more people: blue-eyed homie don't play that. If you think this sounds like an interesting exercise, go right ahead and do it (and feel free to post a comment back to me if you do).

Friday, February 1, 2008

Attention, All Five-Year-Olds

It has come to my attention that there is some confusion out there about a certain word used frequently in the Ice Age movies. So I offer this post as a public service announcement.

Here are three words with different meanings. They sound similar, but have nothing to do with each other. (Well, almost nothing--more on that later.) Do not confuse the meanings of:
  • sloth--a creature with three toes on each foot, recognized specially for its lack of energy. Often they move so slowly that moss grows on their backs. Because of its general languor, the name of this creature has become synonymous with laziness and apathy. The character Sid from the Ice Age movies was from a now-extinct species of sloth (and yes, he was pretty slothful).
  • slob--someone with a high tolerance for clutter and filth. I suspect this word is related to "slovenly", but I'm not sure of the exact connection. Slobs do not feel much need to clean up the messes they make or otherwise find themselves inhabiting. While it is true that Sid was also a slob, and that slovenliness is frequently related to sloth, one cannot usually use the term sloth to mean slob, or slob to mean sloth.
  • Slav--someone descended from one of several Indo-European cultures of Eastern Europe. This word is not related to slovenly. In fact, there are many Slavs who are quite tidy. And if you mistake Slavs for sloths, they will look at you funny and mutter things in deep voices that you probably can't understand.
As I said, I point out this difference for your benefit. Strange things start to happen when you use the wrong word at the wrong time. For example, if you are pretending to be the Fire King from the second Ice Age movie, and you mention to your parents that there is a whole group of Slavs outside waiting to carry you to the nearest volcano, your parents might get alarmed and call the local civil authorities.

And if you refer to your Russian immigrant neighbors (of whom we have many in the Sacramento area) as slobs, you might find yourself getting hauled up before the Diversity Police, who have become increasingly active in our society over the last decade or so.

During the Cold War, we were not continually threatening mutually assured destruction with the Sloths.

Being a Slav is not one of the Seven Deadly Sins.

Slobs don't usually grow moss on their backs. They might grow fungus, but not moss.

Despite whatever conclusions you draw from the Fire King episode, it's not the sloths that have a tendency to authoritarian government. (But note that, like those particular sloths, the Slavs have also shown a recent tendency to sacrifice their political leaders on a semi-regular basis).

Also, note that these three categories are not mutually exclusive. There are slothful Slavs; there are slothful slobs, and there are Slavic slobs. But there are also unslothful Slavs and slobs who aren't Slavs and Slavs who aren't slobs. And there are sloths who aren't slobs, although it's a pretty safe bet that nearly all slobs are slothful.

Have we cleared that up? Good. Now get it right, before your parents erupt into huge guffaws of laughter again. Thank you.

Thursday, January 31, 2008

Here's a Big Shout-Out To All the Other Inbred Mutants Out There!

I've commented before that Foxnews has this way of attaching really spectacular headlines to stories that are actually pretty mundane. It happened again today. This headline has been widely commented upon in the blogosphere, and it was rapidly removed by Foxnews. I suspect that someone got a stern talking-to. Nevertheless, it was good for a laugh while it lasted.

The headline was attached to a story that's been all over the news today, about how the blue-eyed gene only entered the human genome relatively recently. Judging from the genetic record--specifically, which other genes tend to show in people who also have the one for blue eyes--it appears that the blue-eyed gene originated in a fairly isolated community. That is, there was a lot of inbreeding in that original community that allowed blue eyes to become commonplace. This apparently happened before the proto-Indo-European people split up and spread into Europe and central Asia, when our ancestors were still living in communities north of the Black Sea, in what is now Ukraine. This gene is fairly common in Northern Europe, but still shows up occasionally in other ethnic groups descended from the proto-Indo-Europeans, such as the Pashtuns. (Remember that beautiful National Geographic cover with the Afghan girl with the haunting, piercing eyes?)

The headline on Foxnews.com now reads "Scientists: all blue-eyed people are related." But that's not what it read this morning.

Earlier today, it read "Scientists: all blue-eyed people are inbred mutants."

I must object to that, in the strongest possible terms. I'll have you know, I'm not a mutant. :-)

Well, not that I know of, anyway.

Alas, my lovely bride is something of an amateur Geneaologist, and she discovered that my parents are actually tenth cousins. (Oh, the shame....) And she didn't even fill in every nook and cranny in my family tree, which runs through Arkansas and a bunch of other really fun places, so, ummm... Yes, I have blue eyes.

But to be fair, since my three children all have blue eyes too, it means that my lovely brown-eyed wife carries the recessive blue-eyed gene as well. And her family comes from rural Alabama and southwestern Kentucky. I suppose we should be happy our children each have the right number of heads.

So to all my blue-eyed homies out there: Here's a big shout-out to all you glorious inbred mutants! Let those baby blues shine! And if you have red hair too, long may it wave.

Another Odd Snowfall

So first we had the story that Baghdad was hit by snow for the first time in living memory, and I made mention that I briefly wished I could see it in person (before regaining my sanity).

Then, came news that Silicon Valley got a healthy dose of the white stuff.

Now comes news that Jerusalem, of all places, had to shut down because of a major snowfall there.

By way of confession, my first thought was something pretty snarky: let's check the travel schedule of Al Gore and see where he's been lately.

But there's something else to all this that I've noted, in all the stories: There are many, many people out there--even as they face inconvenience (and even danger)--who say, "This is wonderful!" From the Jerusalem story:

The wintry wonderland which Jerusalemites awoke to after days of increasingly-enthusiastic meteorological reports forecasting the great Jerusalem snowfall of 2008 sent children and adults into the streets and parks for snowball fights as a holiday spirit descended on the city.

...

"It's so much fun, and the city looks so clean and white," said Galit Cohen, 11, of Rishon Lezion, who was making a snowman in the city's central Sacher Park at midday.

"We're freezing," her mother Sigal said, dutifully bundled up in hats and gloves as a wintry mix of snow and rain fell from the sky, "but it's wonderful."

And from the earlier Baghdad story:

"When I was young, I heard from my father that such rain had fallen in the early '40s on the outskirts of northern Baghdad," Abdul-Hussein said, referring to snow as a type of rain. "But snow falling in Baghdad in such a magnificent scene was beyond my imagination."

...

Talib Haider, a 19-year-old college student, said "a friend of mine called me at 8 a.m. to wake me up and tell me that the sky is raining snow."

"I rushed quickly to the balcony to see a very beautiful scene," he said. "I tried to film it with my cell phone camera. This scene has really brought me joy. I called my other friends and the morning turned to be a very happy one in my life."

Now, this may be a weird thing to contemplate, giving that half of America is currently freezing its collective tush off--but why is this? Why is it that snow, which from any rational evolutionary perspective should be viewed an absolute disaster, can evoke feelings of such joy and peace? Even among the part of the population that lives in snowy areas--and only with dread anticipates the season of sidewalk shoveling--that first, clean snow of the season nevertheless sure looks beautiful, pristine, peaceful.

And for those of us who have from time to time succumbed to the temptation to associate Middle Easterners with things that go boom, to read stories about long-robed Arab men laughing and getting in snowball fights, tends to re-humanize them, does it not?

So if you're one of those people who's sick of the snow, and this post feels like I have no clue what I'm talking about (and adding insult to your injury), I'm certainly sorry about that. But for all its trouble, I think there's something about snow simply worth celebrating. There's something about it that renews the vigor and uplifts the spirit--for the first ten minutes at least, until everyone gets cold and scrambles to get back inside like sane people.